Quick ? Key saves no ?
- WaterBoy

Quick wasn't as good as he was in their previous cup run.

Why do you think he got traded out of Philly while in his prime ?

I'd take Mike richards of the last decade.
- WaterBoy

Yea looks like that worked out for Philly.

Quick wasn't as good as he was in their previous cup run.
- Pecafan Fan

Not even close. BUT, he did make some huge and timely saves.

LA has a lot more depth.







They don't win the Cup without Kopitar and Doughty.
- Pecafan Fan

Justin Williams, Gaborik, D.Brown, Toffolli, Quick

Quick wasn't as good as he was in their previous cup run.
- Pecafan Fan

he's really not that good. LA is just a ridiculous team.

Not even close. BUT, he did make some huge and timely saves.
- hscesq

Yeah, but so did Lundqvist.

I mean, he was ok, but not THE reason they won.

Not even close. BUT, he did make some huge and timely saves.
- hscesq

Williams was also clutch in the first couple of rounds.

Yea looks like that worked out for Philly.
- mushalain1

flyers got 50 goals out of the guys they got in return for him last season.

he had 11

Justin Williams, Gaborik, D.Brown, Toffolli, Quick
- mushalain1

that's not the point being argued though. obviously LA is far superior to Montreal. the point is that neither team achieves the same level of success they had last year if you remove their top 2 players.

Williams was also clutch in the first couple of rounds.
- WaterBoy

Williams is always clutch.
Vanek gets you there, Williams wins it for you.

flyers got 50 goals out of the guys they got in return for him last season.

he had 11
- Crimsoninja

YOU GUYS GOT SCREWED HAHAHAHAHA!!!

that's not the point being argued though. obviously LA is far superior to Montreal. the point is that neither team achieves the same level of success they had last year if you remove their top 2 players.
- DoubleDown

Mitchell, Martinez, King.

flyers got 50 goals out of the guys they got in return for him last season.

he had 11
- Crimsoninja

Thanks Crums

flyers got 50 goals out of the guys they got in return for him last season.

he had 11
- Crimsoninja

And the Flyers won the Stanley Cup.

YOU GUYS GOT SCREWED HAHAHAHAHA!!!
- BashCH

YOU GUYS GOT SCREWED HAHAHAHAHA!!!
- BashCH

Philly is one of the most mis managed organizations in Hockey. I mean how many bad signings and trades have these guys made in last 20 years? (void John Leclair deal)

How many more decades before they figure out their goalie situation?

And the Flyers won the Stanley Cup.
- hscesq

Philly is one of the most mis managed organizations in Hockey. I mean how many bad signings and trades have these guys made in last 20 years? (void John Leclair deal)

How many more decades before they figure out their goalie situation?
- mushalain1

every team has made bad signings/trades

but do you honestly think the Flyers didnt get good value back in the Richards/Carter trades? I'd make both deals again even in hindsight

And the Flyers won the Stanley Cup.
- hscesq

Doesn't mean it wasn't a good trade for them.

every team has made bad signings/trades

but do you honestly think the Flyers didnt get good value back in the Richards/Carter trades? I'd make both deals again even in hindsight
- Crimsoninja

Except the Leafs.

every team has made bad signings/trades

but do you honestly think the Flyers didnt get good value back in the Richards/Carter trades? I'd make both deals again even in hindsight
- Crimsoninja

Plus, look at the Cups the Flyers won because of those trades.

Doesn't mean it wasn't a good trade for them.
- BashCH

I see.

Plus, look at the Cups the Flyers won because of those trades.
- hscesq

Doesn't mean it wasn't a good trade for them.
- BashCH

Obviously.





That said, they came closer to winning the cup with Richards and Carter than without them.

Obviously.





That said, they came closer to winning the cup with Richards and Carter than without them.
- Pecafan Fan

Details, details.