If I had to pick between a Dman who could put up points, bomb of a shot, can actually remember to do his "D" job for the most part, but might cost a goal by trying a big hit/play or a guy like Karlsson who can put up a poop load of points, run the balls out of a PP and forget the "D" part...Gimme PK any day of the week over him.

Hits the net about 1/50 shots pinches like there's no tomorrow remember http://youtu.be/MfZctQ7kBOE
- Bigern4MVP

So he took 500 shots last year? Doughty is a champ, he was the best player on team Canada.

If I had to pick between a Dman who could put up points, bomb of a shot, can actually remember to do his "D" job for the most part, but might cost a goal by trying a big hit/play or a guy like Karlsson who can put up a poop load of points, run the balls out of a PP and forget the "D" part...Gimme PK any day of the week over him.
- weirdoh

Absolutely, PK is a much more complete player. The guy is about as dynamic as it comes. He is one of the few game changers in the league, and will be paid accordingly.

Absolutely, PK is a much more complete player. The guy is about as dynamic as it comes. He is one of the few game changers in the league, and will be paid accordingly.
- kneughter

I don't trust this

Let's just all agree subban and phaneuf are both poop but subban is slightly better
- Bigern4MVP

lol, wow people are stupid.

Well he is if he wasn't such a hotshot he would be better
- Bigern4MVP

So, so stupid.

lol, wow people are stupid.
- SpoiledByOil

I ain't going back to this original post you quoted. (frank) #3. He's poop.

I don't trust this
- weirdoh

Don't trust what?

I like PK....

If I'm MTL I give him 8 years @8M
- AlfieisKing

Pretty sure that if the Habs were ready to give PK 8x8, it would already been done.

Maybe, the Special Olympics? wink wink
- elcabong

goof

You sure? Go double check
- MTL1

you go double check..

you go double check..
- Daddichronic

2 minutes for double checking!

what olympics were you watching?

- Flyfreaky

he was in the Olympics..just no where near being mvp

he was in the Olympics..just no where near being mvp
- Daddichronic

You are right...that was the Montreal's Goalie..Price

You are right...that was the Montreal's Goalie..Price
- Kaden

cheers bro EXACTLY

You are right...that was the Montreal's Goalie..Price
- Kaden

If I had to pick between a Dman who could put up points, bomb of a shot, can actually remember to do his "D" job for the most part, but might cost a goal by trying a big hit/play or a guy like Karlsson who can put up a poop load of points, run the balls out of a PP and forget the "D" part...Gimme PK any day of the week over him.
- weirdoh

Are you suggesting PK is better than EK65 defensively? They're equal....

- MTL1

hey man im not bias to montreal just idiots who think they no everything and are plain ignorant and no nothing

Are you suggesting PK is better than EK65 defensively? They're equal....
- rangerdanger94

By a landslide. You can ask any forward in the NHL. And they will tell you pk is hard to play against.

hey man im not bias to montreal just idiots who think they no everything and are plain ignorant and no nothing
- Daddichronic

obviously we know that pk didn't play and contributed nothing on the ice

By a landslide. You can ask any forward in the NHL. And they will tell you pk is hard to play against.
- mushalain1

He will have to step it up next year with gorges gone

He will have to step it up next year with gorges gone
- MTL1

Well. I think people under estimate the potential of Emelin. He will be much better playing on the left side. Gorges IMO was over rated. He's a 6th dman on a good club. His shortfalls offensively was his handicap. Sorry but guys like Gorges are a dime a dozen.

By a landslide. You can ask any forward in the NHL. And they will tell you pk is hard to play against.
- mushalain1

Ok show me a quote from ANY nhl forward the directly says pk Subban is harder to play against then Erik karlsson
Take your time

Well. I think people under estimate the potential of Emelin. He will be much better playing on the left side. Gorges IMO was over rated. He's a 6th dman on a good club. His shortfalls offensively was his handicap. Sorry but guys like Gorges are a dime a dozen.
- mushalain1

Who isnt overated in your books?You have just spent most of the day putting down Norris defencemen candidates as in Suter,Seabrook,Chara,etc.

At the least calling them overrated.

Not trying to be a dck just wondering if you know what the ffick your talking about.

obviously we know that pk didn't play and contributed nothing on the ice
- MTL1

There were a few guys claiming he was mvp of Olympics. .I said he wasn't and here we are...soo your agreeing with me..ok (awkward)