Monahan looks like a good player, but I think it's a little early for this type of banter, don't you?
- BetterCallSaul

sheesh. You'd think he was a Leaf fan, talking about his players like that.....

Monahan looks like a good player, but I think it's a little early for this type of banter, don't you?
- BetterCallSaul

Well would you take it or not?


(don't lie)

Monahan - 20 pts in 45 games, -11
Baetschi - 11 pt in 26 games, -4
1st round selection can be from 1-5 (most likely 3rd), probably DalColle or Bennett

Can't assume all of those are automatically greater than 3 players who are in the NHL already, full time, and have had success.

Technically Kadri had a better Jr career, played on Team Canada and in his first 48 game season put up better numbers.
- ILoveLamp

Also, this statement is WAYYYYY off on so many levels.

Agreed.

Although if MB is there to step in, dude will want one more Cup.
And he knows how to make it happen....
- Byfuglien Ate Me

Its true, it wouldn't be the worst trade in the world, and has some goodness, but moving a 25 year old again, post Marty, would be risky...

Well would you take it or not?


(don't lie)
- The-O-G

I didn't backtrack this convo, but what is the point of this? You want to trade us a rookie, who plays top minutes on a shyte team, who has had a decent year...

....for our 2C who racked up at a point a game pace last year?

Monahan - 20 pts in 45 games, -11
Baetschi - 11 pt in 26 games, -4
1st round selection can be from 1-5 (most likely 3rd), probably DalColle or Bennett

Can't assume all of those are automatically greater than 3 players who are in the NHL already, full time, and have had success.

Technically Kadri had a better Jr career, played on Team Canada and in his first 48 game season put up better numbers.
- ILoveLamp

Ya...Kadri had a better junior career because he had a longer junior career.

As far as the world juniors, Kadri only made it after he was drafted. Monahan would have been there had he been available this year.

Nice pinch franson

I must say, I watch the alternate feeds and other broadcasts are finally giving the LEafs respect now, they talk about how they can burn a team, rather than how easy it is to burn the LEafs - its nice

Franson...

No debate for me. I take Clarkson over Leino all day.
- Leafs43

Both Big Contract Busts

Yeah Clarkson is better than Leino, but Komarov was better at his role than Clarkson.

The stuff with Clarkson and Clark at the start of the year makes me sick to watch now

Clark could still outplay or beat the crap out of Clarkson to this day!

For (frank) sakes... What a joke PP

Well would you take it or not?


(don't lie)
- The-O-G

No. Monahan might be the better player when all is said and done, but you don't trade the skill that Kadri has for a maybe.

Gunnar... maybe he needs to be Larry Murphy'd out of town

I didn't backtrack this convo, but what is the point of this? You want to trade us a rookie, who plays top minutes on a shyte team, who has had a decent year...

....for our 2C who racked up at a point a game pace last year?
- IRON.MAIDEN

well sort of....

One of your Leafs brethren offered:

Monahan, 2014 First, Baertschi

for

Kadri, Gardiner, Reimer

then I said

Monahan > Kadri

First > Gardiner

Baertschi > Reimer

No. Monahan might be the better player when all is said and done, but you don't trade the skill that Kadri has for a maybe.
- BetterCallSaul

isn't Kadri STILL a maybe?

well sort of....

One of your Leafs brethren offered:

Monahan, 2014 First, Baertschi

for

Kadri, Gardiner, Reimer

then I said

Monahan > Kadri

First > Gardiner

Baertschi > Reimer
- The-O-G

Did he then point out that you were wrong?

Both Big Contract Busts

Yeah Clarkson is better than Leino, but Komarov was better at his role than Clarkson.

The stuff with Clarkson and Clark at the start of the year makes me sick to watch now

Clark could still outplay or beat the crap out of Clarkson to this day!
- Byfuglien Ate Me

The sad truth of it all...

Ya...Kadri had a better junior career because he had a longer junior career.

As far as the world juniors, Kadri only made it after he was drafted. Monahan would have been there had he been available this year.
- Leafs43

Not to mention he's comparing Monahan's stats this year to Kadri's first "full" NHL season 4 years after he was drafted......

well sort of....

One of your Leafs brethren offered:

Monahan, 2014 First, Baertschi

for

Kadri, Gardiner, Reimer

then I said

Monahan > Kadri

First > Gardiner

Baertschi > Reimer
- The-O-G

gotcha. i wouldnt tke that trade either from CGYs standpoint.

but from a Toronto standpoint, we are moving 3 nhlers for 1 1/2 proven nhlers.
So I wouldnt take that from a toronto standpoint.

isn't Kadri STILL a maybe?
- The-O-G

Not in my opinion. He's still growing as a player, but has shown he should be a very good 2C.

Not in my opinion. He's still growing as a player, but has shown he should be a very good 2C.
- BetterCallSaul

I think Monahan has already shown this as well.

I had no idea tyler johnson was doing so well...

gotcha. i wouldnt tke that trade either from CGYs standpoint.

but from a Toronto standpoint, we are moving 3 nhlers for 1 1/2 proven nhlers.
So I wouldnt take that from a toronto standpoint.
- IRON.MAIDEN

Fair enough....

Either way I think Calgary gets raped in that deal. Not that it makes any sense anyways.

Fair enough....

Either way I think Calgary gets raped in that deal. Not that it makes any sense anyways.
- The-O-G

I agree. Too much youth being tossed around for teams that need REAL leadership...

I agree. Too much youth being tossed around for teams that need REAL leadership...
- IRON.MAIDEN

Gio???