- Cherry--Skoal

Leafs win game... Lose corsi --- happy!


Leafs lose game... Win corsi --- happy!

Holy (frank) no wonder we aren't even close to being contenders when he is considered our best dman.

He is a complimentary top pairing dman at best. IMO he should be a 3 man making 6 milly.
- Pikey Fan

Should, but isn't, so the solution to fixing a weak D shouldn't be to trade the strongest part of it.

As for a 3man, lets not be silly. This is like the Kessel arguement all over again.

I think Gunnar is the type who will be undervalued on the trade market and harder to replace than we think.

Not opposed to moving him if the opportunity is right, but I don't think he'd fetch what he's worth to us.
- Leeman4Gilmour

He's better suited as a 3rd Dman.

Girardi-Phaneuf
Gunnarsson-Franson
Gardiner-Rielly

In the offseason

The salary cap has turned every hockey fan into an amateur accountant.
- Leeman4Gilmour

We're all arm chair GMs to boot.

Leafs overpaid for Clarkson, overpaid for Kessel so might as well over pay for phaneuf too. Since that equation is equaling so many wins!!!

But don't worry the cap will go up guys!

Number 3 dmen dont make 6 million
- jbold

Unless they're on St louis

Should, but isn't, so the solution to fixing a weak D shouldn't be to trade the strongest part of it.

As for a 3man, lets not be silly. This is like the Kessel arguement all over again.
- systemtool

No, he is for sure a number 2 guy

Breaking bad has turned everyone into an amateur chemist also... Barf
- lumlums

Hey now. Dont insult the Canucks fan base like that.

Thats how they pay to get their tickets

I think Gunnar is the type who will be undervalued on the trade market and harder to replace than we think.

Not opposed to moving him if the opportunity is right, but I don't think he'd fetch what he's worth to us.
- Leeman4Gilmour

I felt the same way man, based on how he played last season. But this season, he's horrible. I'm bitter.

Holy (frank) no wonder we aren't even close to being contenders when he is considered our best dman.

He is a complimentary top pairing dman at best. IMO he should be a 3 man making 6 milly.
- Pikey Fan

So, how would you explain all those years he put up #1D numbers?

How do you explain just this year alone?

He's a #1D. We can debate what calibre of #1D he is, but to deny that fact is ignorance.

Sure does. Trade him. Bring in a defensive Dman to play with Dion


Gunnar for Kulikov
- jbold

don't do it man
if Nonis trades players he just signed his gm rating will go down and free agents will refuse to sign with them

Leafs win game... Lose corsi --- happy!


Leafs lose game... Win corsi --- happy!



- robin_steele264

Leafs lose game.. lose corsi... not happy!

The above has been happening a lot lately.

No, he is for sure a number 2 guy
- Pikey Fan

He's probably a number 1 on quite a few teams in the league.

But not the ones competing for cups.

Still not a good excuse to get rid of him.

Hey now. Dont insult the Canucks fan base like that.

Thats how they pay to get their tickets
- jbold

We're all arm chair GMs to boot.

Leafs overpaid for Clarkson, overpaid for Kessel so might as well over pay for phaneuf too. Since that equation is equaling so many wins!!!

But don't worry the cap will go up guys!
- Pikey Fan

But it will. What's the problem here?

We're all arm chair GMs to boot.

Leafs overpaid for Clarkson, overpaid for Kessel so might as well over pay for phaneuf too. Since that equation is equaling so many wins!!!

But don't worry the cap will go up guys!
- Pikey Fan

Go to sleep. Please.

Actually, stay and hopefully get banned. Ill go to sleep.

So, how would you explain all those years he put up #1D numbers?

How do you explain just this year alone?

He's a #1D. We can debate what calibre of #1D he is, but to deny that fact is ignorance.
- Leeman4Gilmour

Well if leafs keep him they need to move a forward to make room cap wise to upgrade phaneuf's supporting cast

That d squad sucks

I was hoping he'd get surgery....actually though he did when he got the extension.....(frank)er didn't get surgery so he (frank)ing sucks still.
- mykokes

He wasn't that great before injury...Looked good on crappy team...He was part reason for crappy team...


Where u expecting bionic limbs with surgery???

Breaking bad has turned everyone into an amateur chemist also... Barf
- lumlums

no it hasn't lums

I think he needs to go.
- mykokes

Nah he just needs to be on the 2nd pair.

Though if Gardiner could play like that every game., life would be much more enjoyable

Breaking bad has turned everyone into an amateur chemist also... Barf
- lumlums

That show taught me that it's possible to throw a party sized pizza onto a roof.

don't do it man
if Nonis trades players he just signed his gm rating will go down and free agents will refuse to sign with them
- Sammich

Thats what I do in NHL14.

Sign free agents. Day later, trade them for first rounders

He's probably a number 1 on quite a few teams in the league.

But not the ones competing for cups.

Still not a good excuse to get rid of him.
- joel878

That's why I'd rather move him for assets and look for a true number 1 guy who deserves 8 mil

no it hasn't lums
- Sammich

Oh, it definitely has for some.

Thats what I do in NHL14.

Sign free agents. Day later, trade them for first rounders
- jbold

(frank)s up your fa's next year

That show taught me that it's possible to throw a party sized pizza onto a roof.
- daeth

Why would you want to do that!?!?!?!