Not even close if RG3 regains his speed. Even at his current speed, I'll take RG3 over Tannehill.


PS: I now know who you are.
- Nucker101

So if RG3 can't run he's not an effective QB?

I think you need to go think about that for awhile.

Wow.

So beating a mediocre/average team with very solid numbers is suddenly a bad thing for a young QB? Okay then.
- Nucker101

Foles is merely keeping the spot warm. Kelly is quoted as saying Bradley is viewed as their future starter.

So if RG3 can't run he's not an effective QB?

I think you need to go think about that for awhile.
- whosyodaddy

See Micheal Vick. Both refuse to adjust their game. And Vick has a far better arm

So if RG3 can't run he's not an effective QB?

I think you need to go think about that for awhile.
- whosyodaddy

Nope, I said I'd still take him over Tannehill eve if he can't ever run like he did last year. He can still run tonight, just lacks the second/explosive gear. I still think he's better than Tannehill as a passer too.

Wow.

So beating a mediocre/average team with very solid numbers is suddenly a bad thing for a young QB? Okay then.
- Nucker101

They haven't won a game and now have a ton of injuries. They aren't average. They are pathetic.

Foles is merely keeping the spot warm. Kelly is quoted as saying Bradley is viewed as their future starter.
- Bieksa#3

Can someone tell me who bradley is? Im guessing you mean Barkley?

Foles is merely keeping the spot warm. Kelly is quoted as saying Bradley is viewed as their future starter.
- Bieksa#3

Link? I read a couple of daily Eagle log sites pretty much everyday even during the off-season and saw no such quote.

Nope, I said I'd still take him over Tannehill eve if he can't ever run like he did last year. He can still run tonight, just lacks the second/explosive gear. I still think he's better than Tannehill as a passer too.
- Nucker101

Vick 3.0

They haven't won a game and now have a ton of injuries. They aren't average. They are pathetic.
- Bieksa#3

QB play and offense in general has sucked. Defense is average, not weak.

Vick 3.0
- Bieksa#3

Better passer. Vick can't throw a touch pass to save his life and has zero adjustment ability.

Nope, I said I'd still take him over Tannehill eve if he can't ever run like he did last year. He can still run tonight, just lacks the second/explosive gear. I still think he's better than Tannehill as a passer too.
- Nucker101

Ryan is getting better. RG3 not so much. Also, RG3 has a running game and o-line for his benefit.

Link? I read a couple of daily Eagle log sites pretty much everyday even during the off-season and saw no such quote.
- Nucker101

Yea Ive never heard chip say that. I think Barkley is going to be terrible. He will draft marriotta next yr.

Ryan is getting better. RG3 not so much. Also, RG3 has a running game and o-line for his benefit.
- whosyodaddy

I agree Tannehill looks better this year, but I'm still giving the edge to RG3 personally even if he doesn't regain his explosive running ability. If Tannehill can continue to improve then I'll definitely eat crow for it.

Yea Ive never heard chip say that. I think Barkley is going to be terrible. He will draft marriotta next yr.
- Bluechip23

Barkley has sucked since he wrecked his shoulder as USC. I hope Foles gets a shot the rest of this season, if he struggles then draft another QB but if he keeps it up then start the kid.

Wow.

So beating a mediocre/average team with very solid numbers is suddenly a bad thing for a young QB? Okay then.
- Nucker101

Bucs are in disarray. They need a coaching change like i've never seen before.

Link? I read a couple of daily Eagle log sites pretty much everyday even during the off-season and saw no such quote.
- Nucker101

It was after the draft. I believe he said they had him as the best QB in the draft I think I've stated before I have no idea with link/GIF posting

Remember, Bradley was considered a lock top 10 pick last yr if he entered draft. Kelly should know the draft talent better then anybody right now

In terms of talent Marino and Elway are the 2 greatest of all time. I think Luck will beat them all when its all said and done.
- Bluechip23

I'd still take Montana when the game is on the line

Better passer. Vick can't throw a touch pass to save his life and has zero adjustment ability.
- Nucker101

When exactly has RG3 adjusted? Vick is a far better runner. A stronger arm. Both are dumb as a stick.

It was after the draft. I believe he said they had him as the best QB in the draft I think I've stated before I have no idea with link/GIF posting

Remember, Bradley was considered a lock top 10 pick last yr if he entered draft. Kelly should know the draft talent better then anybody right now
- Bieksa#3

That was before he ruined his shoulder. Ponder was once viewed as a very good QB prospected before he ruined his shoulder. Carson Palmer was once a hell of a QB in Cincy before he ruined his shoulder too.

I'd still take Montana when the game is on the line
- Zogg

I'll take Eli Manning

Not looking good. Skins are taking over

When exactly has RG3 adjusted? Vick is a far better runner. A stronger arm. Both are dumb as a stick.
- Bieksa#3

I mean adjustments at the line of scrimmage, actually being able to read opposing defenses. Vick's QB IQ is horrid, great arm and legs, zero brain. He's a great for for Kelly's offense, but not the QB of the future.

I'll take Eli Manning

Not looking good. Skins are taking over
- Bieksa#3

Loving the Giants this year, makes it easier to deal with the fact that Philly is retooling.

I agree Tannehill looks better this year, but I'm still giving the edge to RG3 personally even if he doesn't regain his explosive running ability. If Tannehill can continue to improve then I'll definitely eat crow for it.
- Nucker101

I think you'll eat crow. Tannehill was a wideout in college until midway through his junior season. A pretty good one too. He proceded to start 20 games, but his development was hindered by not learning his position. Probably should not have started until about week 12 last year and then just to learn the pro level. He's going to be really good. He shows great touch, just needs to read a bit quicker.

That was before he ruined his shoulder. Ponder was once viewed as a very good QB prospected before he ruined his shoulder. Carson Palmer was once a hell of a QB in Cincy before he ruined his shoulder too.
- Nucker101

Worked out for Manning. Not saying he will be manning but your are clearly inferring its the same for everybody

Worked out for Manning. Not saying he will be manning but your are clearly inferr
- Bieksa#3[quote=Bieksa#3]

Take a look at the pool lately