Lidstrom = best defenseman of all time



*Slithers away*
- AdamFrench

Does Phaneuf exist only outside of time or something? I don't get it.

Lidstrom = best defenseman of all time



*Slithers away*
- AdamFrench

nah - he was gifted on a dynasty team with other quality D men, goaltending and high end forwards.

he was one of the best, but not the best.

to be honest, his game was boring to watch.

I was going to reply to Big D with the same thing. "Not even Lidstrom?"
- Woderwick

lidstrom was great, no doubts, i just dont care for him.

nor do i care for detroit in any which way. the middle east is a more pleasant place. sad yet true.

nah - he was gifted on a dynasty team with other quality D men, goaltending and high end forwards.

he was one of the best, but not the best.

to be honest, his game was boring to watch.
- big_dion

By quality goaltending, you mean Tim Chevaldae and Chris Osgood right?

Leafs PP:

Bozak-Bozak-Bozak

Bozak-Liles

Leafs PP:

Bozak-Bozak-Bozak

Bozak-Liles
- MunsterMike

Bozak should sub in his place

nah - he was gifted on a dynasty team with other quality D men, goaltending and high end forwards.

he was one of the best, but not the best.

to be honest, his game was boring to watch.
- big_dion

Top 3 all time at the very least

I know hockey is great and all... But dude, it's summer.



- robin_steele264

Thank you. Get a life, people. Hockey season is long enough.

Top 3 all time at the very least
- Big_Lightnin

i never said he wasnt top 3.

i just said his game bored me, he never did anything bad, and did everything well, or better than well.

but he wasnt exciting...ever.

Thank you. Get a life, people. Hockey season is long enough.
- Not_Yan

If any of us had lives, we wouldnt be here. Hockey season is not long enough. Not then, not now, not ever.

nah - he was gifted on a dynasty team with other quality D men, goaltending and high end forwards.

he was one of the best, but not the best.

to be honest, his game was boring to watch.
- big_dion

I think that is when he is at his best, when it looks so easy that it seems boring..

What an awesome player.

By quality goaltending, you mean Tim Chevaldae and Chris Osgood right?
- PatC80

so those were the only 2 goalies in the wings dynasty while Lidstrom was around?



good call.

so those were the only 2 goalies in the wings dynasty while Lidstrom was around?



good call.
- big_dion

Hasek wasn't really a goalie. He was more of a goaltender. A netminder, if you will.

I think that is when he is at his best, when it looks so easy that it seems boring..

What an awesome player.
- bixll

yeah i agree, he always was calm and collective.

great D man, but at least you understand what im trying to say...

Hasek wasn't really a goalie. He was more of a goaltender. A netminder, if you will.
- systemtool

Joseph as well.

just a couple hall of famers, no biggy.

Lidstrom = best defenseman of all time



*Slithers away*
- AdamFrench

Bobby Orr was. Let's not be silly.

Bozak should sub in his place
- IrishRage

He's on the 2nd unit.

Bobby Orr was. Let's not be silly.
- systemtool

That's like comparing Tiger Woods to Bobby Jones. 2 different times.

Lid was a better player. Bobby was the innovator.

He's on the 2nd unit.
- MunsterMike

We may be responsible for helping create a global legend known simply as - Bozak.

Fellas, this Bozak thing is getting so (frank)in old, I want to shoot something..

so those were the only 2 goalies in the wings dynasty while Lidstrom was around?



good call.
- big_dion

Well to be fair, Hasek was 96 years old when he went to the Wings and Joseph was not as good as Manny Legace in Detroit

We may be responsible for helping create a global legend known simply as - Bozak.
- Woderwick

To that, we all raise our cups of coffee and cheer "Bozak"

That's like comparing Tiger Woods to Bobby Jones. 2 different times.

Lid was a better player. Bobby was the innovator.
- bixll

Orr 10x better than Lid

Fellas, this Bozak thing is getting so (frank)in old, I want to shoot something..
- bixll

I actually think it's been keeping HH away. It's been so nice