Oilers would be smart to move RNH before his value falls. He is the young gun who will fall.
- thegooddr

Can you please give us the winning numbers for the next Lottery?

Wow no way, they lost to team that has the two best players in the world, I'm shocked our two best players were both coming off injury lol, and we had a few rookies so yeah obviously we lost lol, at least we got to the playoffs
- 6Karlsson5

Excuses

Gardiner for Gagner?! NO THANKS!!!

The Leafs could just sign Bozak who is just a notch below Gagner and keep Gardiner.
No chance a trade like that would happen - Leafs would lose BIGTIME!

Gardiner for Gagner?! NO THANKS!!!

The Leafs could just sign Bozak who is just a notch below Gagner and keep Gardiner.
No chance a trade like that would happen - Leafs would lose BIGTIME!
- Cooshie

Merry Christmas!!!

agreed.

I was just pointing out clear hypocrisy.

you'll notice a lot of people will take whatever side helps their argument whether it has any merit or not.

"who cares that joe smith was -10? his whole team was bad. +/- is a useless stat".

different thread, different day;
"pete jones rules. he had 30 points and was +15"!!

btw-pete jones and joe smith are young and up coming superstars. you just haven't heard of them yet.....
- hugefemale dog77

haha I enjoyed the analogy.

Gardiner for Gagner?! NO THANKS!!!

The Leafs could just sign Bozak who is just a notch below Gagner and keep Gardiner.
No chance a trade like that would happen - Leafs would lose BIGTIME!
- Cooshie

Hilarious.
Oilers fans dont want to trade Gagner for Gardiner.
Leaf fans dont want to trade Gardiner for Gagner.

So what is the problem here?

Hilarious.
Oilers fans dont want to trade Gagner for Gardiner.
Leaf fans dont want to trade Gardiner for Gagner.

So what is the problem here?
- Jeropotato

The problem is that we need a new BLOG,so Clouts get to work.

Hilarious.
Oilers fans dont want to trade Gagner for Gardiner.
Leaf fans dont want to trade Gardiner for Gagner.

So what is the problem here?
- Jeropotato

LOL - true!!
From a Leafs perspective though - it makes no sense when they can resign Bozak and just keep Gardiner. Bozak isn't Gagner but he's not far off either.

Put it this way - the difference between Bozak and Gagner is not Gardiner!

If Gagner doesnt help bring you back a top pairing defenseman, you pay the man. Period.

Hilarious.
Oilers fans dont want to trade Gagner for Gardiner.
Leaf fans dont want to trade Gardiner for Gagner.

So what is the problem here?
- Jeropotato

That people keep suggesting dumb trades...???

Hilarious.
Oilers fans dont want to trade Gagner for Gardiner.
Leaf fans dont want to trade Gardiner for Gagner.

So what is the problem here?
- Jeropotato

good post

Leafs - Oilers threads make for great discussion

Wouldn't trade Gardiner for Gagner straight up. I don't think Nonis would either.

Oilers would be smart to move RNH before his value falls. He is the young gun who will fall.
- thegooddr

we'll take this under consideration. thank you for your input

That people keep suggesting dumb trades...???
- lumlums

yup

Hilarious.
Oilers fans dont want to trade Gagner for Gardiner.
Leaf fans dont want to trade Gardiner for Gagner.

So what is the problem here?
- Jeropotato

There is a good potential for some sort of trade between the Leafs and Edmonton.
Gagner for Gardiner is not it.

Leafs - Oilers threads make for great discussion
- robin_steele264

like banging your head against a brick wall repeatedly

MY God....11 pages and counting. Clouts is counting on all the stupid people to come and argue over this and sure enough....

He's been nothing but consistent since his rookie season. Do you ever get tired of being an idiot?
- TheTaoOfSemenko

LOL. I guess you're the idiot for saying he's been consistent since his rookie season. Now I know you know nothing about hockey & i'm done responding to you.

Wouldn't trade Gardiner for Gagner straight up. I don't think Nonis would either.
- Jeffmt

MacT feels the same is Gardiner plus....

I only said Gagner Value higher right now because of the amount of years he have already play and show he can produce,Gardiner had only One season with yes great potential but He only have one season under his belt so if He keeps producing the same or better in the next 2 to 3 years then I will said his value is higher but right now Gagner have that advantage IMO.
- AlEx_OiL

Fair enough. Still value Gardiner more though because of that great potential. (Not to say gagner wont get better as well)

I don't believe Dion Phaneuf is going to get any better but Gagner at 23 have more potential to improve and be the better player of the two.
- AlEx_OiL

As of now I would think p9 is worth more but like I said before WTF DO I KNOW

MY God....11 pages and counting. Clouts is counting on all the stupid people to come and argue over this and sure enough....


- Iggysbff

is sunday afternoon,just having some fun

MacT feels the same is Gardiner plus....
- AlEx_OiL

He might as well just save his breath then.

Phaneuf for Gagner, straight across is about right.
- seanjohn667

Nope, Phanuef plays a huge role for our team despite the hate he gets. Our D would be terrible with him gone.