Like TJ says, Id try to go for Elder.
- aecliptic

He got a big contract tho.

Garrison and burrows for Girardi and ??
- Chris Erwin

Garrison? Youre kidding right?

No thanks!
- aecliptic

What? You'd rather have Girardi over Hamhuis? Crazy.

What? You'd rather have Girardi over Hamhuis? Crazy.
- Blackstrom2

Serious?

He got a big contract tho.
- Slimtj100

What do you think Girardi will demand next year? Might not be 5 mil, but it probably wont be too far off... maybe in the 4.25-4.5m range.

Serious?
- Slimtj100

Girardi is the most over-rated defenseman in the league. Well, besides Green.

Garrison? Youre kidding right?
- aecliptic

Yea no way

I like him before he got oodles of undeserved coin

Garrison? Youre kidding right?
- aecliptic

Burrows for sandpaper and some goals and garrison for his shot on pp. Girardi good but he isn't Bobby Orr.

You notice the last two seasons Girardi sort of fade towards end of season. I hated him for not taking third man in on Carcillo against Gabby that time but he became one of my favorites. That being said he isn't getting younger and has a lot of city miles on him. Don't think those late season fades are going to stop if not get worse.
- Chris Erwin

That could have something to do with him playing 87 minutes a night. You take a minutes eater, warrior like him and you'll miss him

Girardi is the most over-rated defenseman in the league. Well, besides Green.
- Blackstrom2

You are off your rockah

What do you think Girardi will demand next year? Might not be 5 mil, but it probably wont be too far off... maybe in the 4.25-4.5m range.
- aecliptic

Another team will pay him over 5 million. Maybe the Rangers get a home town discount.

You are off your rockah
- Slimtj100

I've gone into it before. Marc Staal is your best defenseman, and has been for a few years.

Girardi is the most over-rated defenseman in the league. Well, besides Green.
- Blackstrom2

What are basing that on, ovechkins 1 lucky bounce goal in the playoffs?

Burrows for sandpaper and soe goals and garrison for his shot on pp. Girardi good but he isn't Bobby Orr.
- Chris Erwin

Garrison is making 4.6m per year... Unless the Canucks are willing to eat 1.5-2m on his contract, I want no part of him. Hes not that good outside of him having a slap shot.

Dylan McIlrath has been clocked at 90mph on his slap shot in juniors.

Girardi is the most over-rated defenseman in the league. Well, besides Green.
- Blackstrom2

I think he us the most underrated. Just a matter of opinion I guess.

What are basing that on, ovechkins 1 lucky bounce goal in the playoffs?
- Slimtj100

Yes, because Ovechkin scored 1 goal all series, the Rangers defense is God's defense.

I've gone into it before. Marc Staal is your best defenseman, and has been for a few years.
- Blackstrom2

You might wanna rephrase it then. Girardi is not Overated . He actully is probably the most underrated in the leauge

Girardi is the most over-rated defenseman in the league. Well, besides Green.
- Blackstrom2

Dumbest post of the year. Your opinion really means nothing now.

That could have something to do with him playing 87 minutes a night. You take a minutes eater, warrior like him and you'll miss him
- Pete V

I agree but was basing proposal or idea on both coaches would want one or two of their guys. And only one of Torts guys since there wasn't exactly a plethora Girardi would be guy targeted not saying rangers would do it just tossing hypotheticals out there

Dumbest post of the year. Your opinion really means nothing now.
- GioRock

Thats the point, its an opinion... like azzholes, everyone has got one.

Yes, because Ovechkin scored 1 goal all series, the Rangers defense is God's defense.
- Blackstrom2

Girardi had some of that responsibility. He held the MVP of the NHL to 1 playoff goal. Perhaps he should've been the MVP?

You might wanna rephrase it then. Girardi is not Overated . He actully is probably the most underrated in the leauge
- Slimtj100

No, not at all. All that hype last year.

I'm taking McD over Girardi 10/10 times.

Girardi had some of that responsibility. He held the MVP of the NHL to 1 playoff goal. Perhaps he should've been the MVP?
- Slimtj100

No, perhaps Ovi shouldn't have been MVP. Which is what I said multiple times before and after he won the award.

I agree but was basing proposal or idea on both coaches would want one or two of their guys. And only one of Torts guys since there wasn't exactly a plethora Girardi would be guy targeted not saying rangers would do it just tossing hypotheticals out there
- Chris Erwin

I get you point, but I think Girardi mean a great deal to the makeup of the team, even outside of what he does on the ice.

I get you point, but I think Girardi mean a great deal to the makeup of the team, even outside of what he does on the ice.
- Pete V

That stuff is invaluable, which makes it all the more harder to trade him.