Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!
 
Forums :: Blog World :: John Toperzer: Penguins Thursday: Iginla or Dupuis poll
Author Message
powerhouse
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Columbia , MD
Joined: 11.28.2006

May 16 @ 4:20 PM ET
I really don't mind the Neal for goose trade, both are pretty 1 demensional and streaky as hell.

Just curious of the return you guys are expexcting if letang is traded. And am I the only one who thinks he looks like a werewolf?

- NoobasaurusRex


Never knew Neal was so one dimensional. Moody too.
jmatchett383
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Newark, DE
Joined: 03.09.2010

May 16 @ 4:23 PM ET
This is true, but one thing that Carolina knew, was that Staal would resign there. Whoever trades for Letang is going to want to be assured that he will resign there and what it will likely cost.

And you'd have to get a high pick, but you'd have to get back at least one really good, young roster player. The way this team is set now, you can't wait around for picks and prospects to develop, they would need to be able to plug someone in for another run now.

- rival22


Which is why I said not to trade him. As good as he is, Malkin will always be second fiddle to Crosby (assuming he stays healthy). Plus, the return for Malkin would be...wow. If you traded him to a team that needs a Marquee player to promote the team (Florida), imagine the return. Huberdeau, the 2nd overall pick (MacKinnon), and Markstrom to start. Maybe also Weiss and another 1st rounder. I know it probably sounds crazy, but I think Letang is the smarter money.
nelson911
Pittsburgh Penguins
Joined: 02.03.2007

May 16 @ 4:24 PM ET
My opinion of the Edler hit, was he was going to lay into him then let up because Staal dished the puck off... I don't think he intended to destroy his knee... unfortunate result... I'd give him 1-2 games off for not at least trying to lift his leg up... mind you he does sort of pull his leg back away from Staal but the collision happens... although at pro hockey speed its almost impossible to react to certain situations.

I don't want to be one of the slow motion replay analysts that Im growing tired of.
kill.monsters
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Kansas City, MO
Joined: 05.02.2011

May 16 @ 4:31 PM ET
Which is why I said not to trade him. As good as he is, Malkin will always be second fiddle to Crosby (assuming he stays healthy). Plus, the return for Malkin would be...wow. If you traded him to a team that needs a Marquee player to promote the team (Florida), imagine the return. Huberdeau, the 2nd overall pick (MacKinnon), and Markstrom to start. Maybe also Weiss and another 1st rounder. I know it probably sounds crazy, but I think Letang is the smarter money.
- jmatchett383

I agree 100%. Now, having said that I'd prefer to see 87 and 71 grow old together, sticking with $8.7M contracts until they turn 35 when they would drop down to $3M for 5 years ultimately retiring together in 2027 after lifting their 7th Stanley Cup at ages 40 and 41.
MrFurly
Ottawa Senators
Location: Ottawa, ON
Joined: 08.26.2006

May 16 @ 4:46 PM ET
Dam, I was hoping this blog was about injuries to Iginla and Dupuis

You guys should bench Malkin, he and Crosby could use the rest! Of course last time you did that we still lost!
Francois Leroux
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: New Castle, DE
Joined: 07.10.2009

May 16 @ 4:46 PM ET
I think Neal has been playing well the last few games. He isn't scoring, but he's been skating hard and played well on the forecheck in GM #1.
- rival22


I agree.. He has had some pep in his step. I like it!
s0rcerer1984
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: United States, VA
Joined: 07.03.2008

May 16 @ 4:48 PM ET
My Priority order this offseason:

1. extend/trade Letang
2. extend Malkin
3. re-sign Dupuis
4. extend Kunitz
5. re-sign Cooke
6. sign Murray
7. sign Iginla
8. sign Morrow

- cap1681


Realize I'm responding super-late to this, but the way you phrased it bothered. We'd be extending Malkin, Kunitz, & Letang, which is quite a bit different than re-signing then as either a UFA or a RFA.

Also, i'd alter the order slightly:

1. extend/trade Letang
2. extend Malkin
3. re-sign Dupuis
4. sign Iginla
5. sign Murray
6. re-sign Cooke

I'd let Morrow & Kennedy walk. Next year we'd have Iginlia, Dupuis, Kunitz, & Neal on the Top-6 W's with Bennett & Cooke being centered by Sutter. Bennett is the wild-card as he could play Top-6 W or be used to add some scoring skill to the 3rd line.
jmatchett383
Philadelphia Flyers
Location: Newark, DE
Joined: 03.09.2010

May 16 @ 4:51 PM ET
Realize I'm responding super-late to this, but the way you phrased it bothered. We'd be extending Malkin, Kunitz, & Letang, which is quite a bit different than re-signing then as either a UFA or a RFA.

Also, i'd alter the order slightly:

1. extend/trade Letang
2. extend Malkin
3. re-sign Dupuis
4. sign Iginla
5. sign Murray
6. re-sign Cooke

I'd let Morrow & Kennedy walk. Next year we'd have Iginlia, Dupuis, Kunitz, & Neal on the Top-6 W's with Bennett & Cooke being centered by Sutter. Bennett is the wild-card as he could play Top-6 W or be used to add some scoring skill to the 3rd line.

- s0rcerer1984


You think you'll be able to sing both Iginla and Dupuis after extending Malkin and giving Letang his raise? I'm assuming we're talking multi-year deals for Iginla and Dupuis which will carry into the Letang/Malkin extensions.
s0rcerer1984
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: United States, VA
Joined: 07.03.2008

May 16 @ 5:06 PM ET
You think you'll be able to sing both Iginla and Dupuis after extending Malkin and giving Letang his raise? I'm assuming we're talking multi-year deals for Iginla and Dupuis which will carry into the Letang/Malkin extensions.
- jmatchett383


Pens will have $8.5M in Cap space next year w/ a base roster as follows:

XXXXX-Crosby-Kunitz
XXXXX-Malkin-Neal
Bennett-Sutter-Jokinen
XXXXX-Vitale-Glass

Martin-Orpik
Letang-Despres
Niskanen-Engeland

Add depth w/ Bortuzzo (RFA) at $600K & Adams at $700K w/ a total remaining cap of $7.2M.

$7.2M could work out to Iginlia at $3.5M and Dupuis at $3M is possible w/ $700K left over, but who knows? Just have to wait & see.

Pens have a ton of contracts expiring in 2014 (Jokinen, Kunitz, Glass, Orpik, Niskanen) so Cap sapce for Letang and Malkin's extensions shouldn't an issue, though a mini-tool will be needed in 2014-15 & going forward from what the team is now.
Orpik44
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Wooooo!Bring it on Flyer wussies!
Joined: 06.04.2011

May 16 @ 5:14 PM ET
In other Worlds injury news, I guess Sweden's Alex Edler (Canucks) blew out Eric Staal's knee with what everyone is saying was a dirty hit. I haven't seen it, the youtube videos seemed to be pulled down for copyright infringement.

edit: Here's a crappy video of it-

https://vine.co/v/bE66j3KgmXi

Yay... bad hit. No reason to come into him like that.

- rival22

This video was actually pretty good. Reminds me a lot of the hit Ovi laid on Gleason and Gonchar. He should be suspended for it.
Oneonta Penguin
Pittsburgh Penguins
Joined: 07.02.2007

May 16 @ 5:18 PM ET
If letang doesn't sign and wants rediculous money what would his trade value be? same as staals basically, I good player that is obviously being traded?
Our 10th a top prospect and an average prospect?

You guys owe us one for Neal still.

- NoobasaurusRex


He should get more in return. We don't owe you anything for Neal. Your GM, err ex-GM didn't think so. You don't have enough to get Letang in a deal.
Orpik44
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Wooooo!Bring it on Flyer wussies!
Joined: 06.04.2011

May 16 @ 5:18 PM ET
Yeah... this is apparently it:


He brings a lot on himself, but the guy can't win. He lets those shots go through and they score, then the Milbury's of the world question his heart.

- rival22

I guess he broke it going in the first block. That's the best defensive effort I've seen from him, ever.
Orpik44
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Wooooo!Bring it on Flyer wussies!
Joined: 06.04.2011

May 16 @ 5:20 PM ET
If letang doesn't sign and wants rediculous money what would his trade value be? same as staals basically, I good player that is obviously being traded?
Our 10th a top prospect and an average prospect?

You guys owe us one for Neal still.

- NoobasaurusRex

I'd be glad to take Benn or Eriksson (love his contract). Choose one for us
Orpik44
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Wooooo!Bring it on Flyer wussies!
Joined: 06.04.2011

May 16 @ 5:29 PM ET
Pens will have $8.5M in Cap space next year w/ a base roster as follows:

XXXXX-Crosby-Kunitz
XXXXX-Malkin-Neal
Bennett-Sutter-Jokinen
XXXXX-Vitale-Glass

Martin-Orpik
Letang-Despres
Niskanen-Engeland

Add depth w/ Bortuzzo (RFA) at $600K & Adams at $700K w/ a total remaining cap of $7.2M.

$7.2M could work out to Iginlia at $3.5M and Dupuis at $3M is possible w/ $700K left over, but who knows? Just have to wait & see.

Pens have a ton of contracts expiring in 2014 (Jokinen, Kunitz, Glass, Orpik, Niskanen) so Cap sapce for Letang and Malkin's extensions shouldn't an issue, though a mini-tool will be needed in 2014-15 & going forward from what the team is now.

- s0rcerer1984


That's pretty good. We could always trade Niskanen if we feel Despres is ready to take on his duties...give the money to Iggy/Dupper/Murray.
kill.monsters
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Kansas City, MO
Joined: 05.02.2011

May 16 @ 5:38 PM ET
I'd be glad to take Benn or Eriksson (love his contract). Choose one for us
- Orpik44

Eriksson's contract is wonderful.
madmike71
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: 12.21.2006

May 16 @ 6:47 PM ET
I guess Torres needs to change his name to Rick Nash then Shanny would see things differently.
Orpik44
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Wooooo!Bring it on Flyer wussies!
Joined: 06.04.2011

May 16 @ 6:56 PM ET
I guess Torres needs to change his name to Rick Nash then Shanny would see things differently.
- madmike71


Torres is in a bad position. His name is becoming worse than Cooke's around the league.

Does he has the talent to become a Cooke type of player (like he's now)?
Orpik44
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Wooooo!Bring it on Flyer wussies!
Joined: 06.04.2011

May 16 @ 6:57 PM ET
Eriksson's contract is wonderful.
- kill.monsters

Can you imagine Eriksson on Geno's wing? wow...just too much talent in one line
thickman1178
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: NJ
Joined: 02.21.2013

May 16 @ 7:01 PM ET
I guess he broke it going in the first block. That's the best defensive effort I've seen from him, ever.
- Orpik44


And after he broke his foot, probably the last one you'll see from him as well. Im surprised he did it in the first place but I guess those ghosts of playoffs past got to him.
thickman1178
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: NJ
Joined: 02.21.2013

May 16 @ 7:11 PM ET
My opinion of the Edler hit, was he was going to lay into him then let up because Staal dished the puck off... I don't think he intended to destroy his knee... unfortunate result... I'd give him 1-2 games off for not at least trying to lift his leg up... mind you he does sort of pull his leg back away from Staal but the collision happens... although at pro hockey speed its almost impossible to react to certain situations.

I don't want to be one of the slow motion replay analysts that Im growing tired of.

- nelson911



Yeah its always hard to tell from the slow mo replays but that looks pretty dirty. It looks like he thought Staal was gonna come up and maybe turn forehand with the puck and then he just decided to clip him while Staals leg was extended. Im sure he didn't mean to do that much damage, but it happened none the less.
SuperHenderson13
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: 10.13.2008

May 16 @ 7:15 PM ET
the asking price for Letang would be HIGH. and I mean high.

I would see, good roster player, great prospect, 1st round pick... and maybe more.

hopefully we extend letang at a reasonable rate. I think he understands that his game is going to benefit if he is in pitt.

I see him taking a little bit more than what karlsson took. right in that range. perfectly fine with that. guy deserves to get paid.
Orpik44
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Wooooo!Bring it on Flyer wussies!
Joined: 06.04.2011

May 16 @ 7:19 PM ET
the asking price for Letang would be HIGH. and I mean high.

I would see, good roster player, great prospect, 1st round pick... and maybe more.

hopefully we extend letang at a reasonable rate. I think he understands that his game is going to benefit if he is in pitt.

I see him taking a little bit more than what karlsson took. right in that range. perfectly fine with that. guy deserves to get paid.

- SuperHenderson13

$6.5M max. from us, please.

Geno at $9M sounds cool too.

If we trade him it will be either to Anaheim or Edmonton. Take note.
SuperHenderson13
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: 10.13.2008

May 16 @ 7:23 PM ET
and of the following teams, who makes the big move first?

VAN, PHI, WSH, STL?

my money's on Vancouver.
SuperHenderson13
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Joined: 10.13.2008

May 16 @ 7:23 PM ET
$6.5M max. from us, please.

Geno at $9M sounds cool too.

If we trade him it will be either to Anaheim or Edmonton. Take note.

- Orpik44

I could see us trading him to ANA

for Fowler, Etem and a 1st. that wouldn't be a horrible deal IMO for either side.
Orpik44
Pittsburgh Penguins
Location: Wooooo!Bring it on Flyer wussies!
Joined: 06.04.2011

May 16 @ 7:24 PM ET
and of the following teams, who makes the big move first?

VAN, PHI, WSH, STL?

my money's on Vancouver.

- SuperHenderson13

Yeah, they HAVE to. The Sedins are already on their 30s and they don't look like a tough team built for the playoffs.

Saint Louis has to do something as well....

I don't care about the FLyers
Page: Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8  Next