Canucks need to lower their cap number, they will most likely want Simmonds over Hartnell.
- BiggE

If we want schenn in the mix, who would you guys want coming back?

Honestly, as a Flyers fan, I would strongly consider trading Simmonds for Edler. As much as I like Simmonds, the Flyers have several good forwards and a definite need on defense.

It'd definitely depend on the terms involved, but I think most Flyers fans would agree, because they have such a need for a solid, mobile top 4 defenseman like Edler.
- Jsaquella

Simmonds is exactly what this team needs

Id rather trade Hartnell...Too many pentalies. Simmonds is younger and faster.
- BernieKorch

Hartnell is now too old

Ottawa could use Edler but it would not be a package involving a top roster player. I think they could part with their 1st and Mark Stone though for Edler no problem!
- riceroni

That would be interesting. Maybe need a "throw in" type roster player, but doable

That would be interesting. Maybe need a "throw in" type roster player, but doable
- IanEsplen

I dont like that trade...
A playoff pick and a prospect that hasnt been anywhere the last year isnt good enough for a d-man that can put up 40-50 points
Edler may be inconsistent but he has put up the numbers

This is actually laughable... thanks for cheering me up after that loss last night

I dont like that trade...
A playoff pick and a prospect that hasnt been anywhere the last year isnt good enough for a d-man that can put up 40-50 points
Edler may be inconsistent but he has put up the numbers
- RF_4eva

Agreed

I dont like that trade...
A playoff pick and a prospect that hasnt been anywhere the last year isnt good enough for a d-man that can put up 40-50 points
Edler may be inconsistent but he has put up the numbers
- RF_4eva

I'd hardly call 38 points in 54 games as an AHL rookie doing nothing.

He'll be a big-bodied, 50-70 point guy one day and he is a cheap cap number.

The first pick will very likely be around 18-20 in a good draft.

the value wouldn't be that bad.

I'd hardly call 38 points in 54 games as an AHL rookie doing nothing.

He'll be a big-bodied, 50-70 point guy one day and he is a cheap cap number.

The first pick will very likely be around 18-20 in a good draft.

the value wouldn't be that bad.
- IanEsplen

A trade we can make but not with edler
IMO Edler can get more than that

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH no way you are getting any of those guys... im sorry dude is what 4.5 mil and is an ok dman at best the whole league knows the nucks need to shead cap and no one is going to help them or make it easier, think of the luongo situation. might as well start shoping the sisters to new york now
- Buc Nasty68

?????

A big cheer for good old literacy.

You're severely undervaluing Bergeron in that trade proposal. He does it all, he may not put up 80+ points a year but he plays all 3 zones and is one of the top faceoff guys in the NHL if not the best. Chiarelli would trade everyone on the roster before he moved Bergeron, especially for Edler.

You're severely undervaluing Bergeron in that trade proposal. He does it all, he may not put up 80+ points a year but he plays all 3 zones and is one of the top faceoff guys in the NHL if not the best. Chiarelli would trade everyone on the roster before he moved Bergeron, especially for Edler.
- fudd1689

We have a player like that. We need scoring and Bruins don't need a Dman

This is actually laughable... thanks for cheering me up after that loss last night
- steve362

That's all it took to cheer you up?
You must not be that big of a Leafs fan.

Edler, Booth and Luongo (14ish) for Vanek, Meyers and Kaleta (13.8ish)

BUF could then trade Miller for an immediate return.

Both Meyers and Edler get a new start.

If we want schenn in the mix, who would you guys want coming back?
- RF_4eva

I wouldn't want to part with Schenn, my best offer would be Simmonds, this years 2nd pick #41 and a prospect.

We have a player like that. We need scoring and Bruins don't need a Dman
- VANTEL

The Bruins could actually use a Dman. Chara is turning 37 next year and it appears Ference may be on his way out this summer during free agency. That only leaves Hamilton, Boychuck and Seidenberg with a 37 year old Chara.

So you expect to get a top prospect in Strome for what you call the Canucks 3rd best left handed d-man?

If we want schenn in the mix, who would you guys want coming back?
- RF_4eva

The Twins but Id throw back a prospect or a pick so

Hartnell
Schenn
Briere

for

Edler
H Sedin
D Sedin

I wouldn't want to part with Schenn, my best offer would be Simmonds, this years 2nd pick #41 and a prospect.
- BiggE

Thats way too much for this D man

The Twins but Id throw back a prospect or a pick so

Hartnell
Schenn
Briere

for

Edler
H Sedin
D Sedin
- BernieKorch

That would get you one Sedin.

Some of those offers are good. Others, not so good.

Love all the fans of other teams saying "you're crazy", and then some of the fans of the teams proposed in the deals coming in and saying they'd make the deal...

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH no way you are getting any of those guys... im sorry dude is what 4.5 mil and is an ok dman at best the whole league knows the nucks need to shead cap and no one is going to help them or make it easier, think of the luongo situation. might as well start shoping the sisters to new york now
- Buc Nasty68

I dont like that trade...
A playoff pick and a prospect that hasnt been anywhere the last year isnt good enough for a d-man that can put up 40-50 points
Edler may be inconsistent but he has put up the numbers
- RF_4eva

You never know. A young, injury prone roster with a few guys potentially retiring. It's a gamble, for sure, but that pick could be anywhere.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH no way you are getting any of those guys... im sorry dude is what 4.5 mil and is an ok dman at best the whole league knows the nucks need to shead cap and no one is going to help them or make it easier, think of the luongo situation. might as well start shoping the sisters to new york now
- Buc Nasty68

I think just about every one of those trades is doable, other than Bergeron and Strome. Skinner is kind of iffy too.

That would get you one Sedin's jock strap .
- Fosco

FIXED