No.
To be a bit of a homer, I wouldn't trade Eberle for almost anyone.
- abware

How about Hall for Benn?

How about Hall for Benn?
- yaktalksback

I think Benn is more of what the Oilers need, more of an all round physical player, but I believe Hall has a higher offensive ceiling and will in time become a physical player himself. It would probably be a good trade but I wouldn't do it because of the chemistry and morale of having Eberle and Hall together.
As an Oiler fan I want to see them and Nuge in Oiler silks for a long time.
Homerish yes, but my opinion

this
- hugefemale dog77

If it gets your team a better player, you do it. Don't get me wrong, Hall is an amazing player. But not the best by a long shot.

I don't see COL want anything to do with Gagner. COL already has Duchene and Stastny. I don't think EDM would want Duchene or Stastny coming back.

If it gets your team a better player, you do it. Don't get me wrong, Hall is an amazing player. But not the best by a long shot.
- Deadmau55

? That was in response to not trading Eberle.

If it gets your team a better player, you do it. Don't get me wrong, Hall is an amazing player. But not the best by a long shot.
- Deadmau55

this is in reference to eberle.

and again, there's very few players i would trade eberle for

You know how they say, "don't hate the playa, hate the game?"

Thanks for increasing my hit count.
- Maxbone

Serious question - what's the straight goods on Paarjarvi-Svensson? Trade bait, a work in progress and developing, not going to make it in Edmonton?

Serious question - what's the straight goods on Paarjarvi-Svensson? Trade bait, a work in progress and developing, not going to make it in Edmonton?
- RickJ

Developing him in a shut down role, and PK.

Serious question - what's the straight goods on Paarjarvi-Svensson? Trade bait, a work in progress and developing, not going to make it in Edmonton?
- RickJ

I say work in progress and developing into a certain type of player and then trade bait.

never get sick of it

Serious question - what's the straight goods on Paarjarvi-Svensson? Trade bait, a work in progress and developing, not going to make it in Edmonton?
- RickJ

I think the Oilers have lowered their expectations and realize Paajarvi is likely a career third-line LW who kills penalties and contributes a point once in a while.

Like I said before, I believe you know someone who knows someone, but that is hardly a source. That or someone in the know is feeding you what they want you to say because there are a lot of people here.(even though most come across as ass hats
- abware

The great thing about guys like you is, you wouldn't even believe it if I took the time to explain it to you.

I don't see COL want anything to do with Gagner. COL already has Duchene and Stastny. I don't think EDM would want Duchene or Stastny coming back.
- deks1

I'd take Duchene over Gagner, straight up.

I think the Oilers have lowered their expectations and realize Paajarvi is likely a career third-line LW who kills penalties and contributes a point once in a while.
- Maxbone

Well, I guess that's better than the #1 pick we got the year before in Kyle Beach. He contributes nothing.

Jim just got his penis caught in the computer when his kid caught him masturbating and then he went into the bathroom and his wife was getting herself off with the shower head set on a massage setting.
- ShooterMcGavin

Are you also Mark Spector?

http://www.sportsnet.ca/h..._edmonton_oilers_rumours/

Your blog, scenarios, and conclusions strangely mirror his article, or are you merely plagiarizing his work?

I'd take Duchene over Gagner, straight up.
- Maxbone

Me too, I think COL would also take Duchene over Gagner. So Gagner ain't going near COL.

Are you also Mark Spector?

http://www.sportsnet.ca/h..._edmonton_oilers_rumours/

Your blog, scenarios, and conclusions strangely mirror his article, or are you merely plagiarizing his work?
- RoloTahmasee

No.

The great thing about guys like you is, you wouldn't even believe it if I took the time to explain it to you.
- Maxbone

The great thing about guys like you is you actually believe your own bs.

I kid, I kid. I do like most of your blogs, but you push your opinion as fact too much. And not just since you say you have source(s).
If you do indeed have a source now don't act like an in the know tool because even insiders are fed bs

Are you also Mark Spector?

http://www.sportsnet.ca/h..._edmonton_oilers_rumours/

Your blog, scenarios, and conclusions strangely mirror his article, or are you merely plagiarizing his work?
- RoloTahmasee

Maybe they have the same source
Or Spectors articles are the source

Me too, I think COL would also take Duchene over Gagner. So Gagner ain't going near COL.
- deks1

I really like Gagner as a player but I don't think Edmonton is a spot for him long term. One thing he's proved is that at center, he's an effective top6 player but only at center. His good games on the wing are few and far between.

It could make him difficult to move to really get fair value in a deal.

Sam Gagner wont even get you one of our draft picks.
- Drij

yet Cloutier overvalues EDM players. aha

Are you also Mark Spector?

http://www.sportsnet.ca/h..._edmonton_oilers_rumours/

Your blog, scenarios, and conclusions strangely mirror his article, or are you merely plagiarizing his work?
- RoloTahmasee

Ouch...busted.

I'd take Duchene over Gagner, straight up.
- Maxbone

you mean the guy who put up 67 points in his sophomore season over a guy who peaked at 49? shocked

I really like Gagner as a player but I don't think Edmonton is a spot for him long term. One thing he's proved is that at center, he's an effective top6 player but only at center. His good games on the wing are few and far between.

It could make him difficult to move to really get fair value in a deal.
- DTF69

I can see Gagner going to NSH, PHX, WPG, maybe TOR or NJD...then there is VAN because of the Luongo rumor.