Screw it....Im adding Hull, Drury, Amonte, Nolan, St Louis, Savard
- Colin Dambrauskas

Then we have to go back and get Grant Fuhr on the goalie list.

and hey, what about Jim Craig???

Then we have to go back and get Grant Fuhr on the goalie list.

and hey, what about Jim Craig???
- scoot174

I say we should have dibs on any player who's BEEN to Calgary!

I think you missed a center....

I think you missed a center....


- Reveen

...wouldnt be fair to add him, Oilers fans would complain that we're cheating!

I think you missed a center....


- Reveen

He'll be on the list during the next lockout in 5-8 years

Wow, I can't believe the lack of love for Lanks and the excessive love for Otto. I like Otto as well but he was a defensive specialist who was stellar at faceoffs.

For me it's Neuwy, Gilmour, Nilsson & Langkow. Conny would have been my spare. Purely as a Flame, Lanks makes this list. Cammy, to me is a LW, I just have trouble voting for him as a centerman.

But yea, as a whole, it's a pretty sad group after the 1st 2. Maybe we do this in 10 years and Janko tops that list.
- TandA4Flames

Or maybe in 10 yrs...people ask...Mark Jankwho?

Or maybe in 10 yrs...people ask...Mark Jankwho?
- Iggysbff

Or maybe Clouts does this in 10 years and it's said "Edmonton who???"

Or maybe Clouts does this in 10 years and it's said "Edmonton who???"
- TandA4Flames

when they do the seattle alltime team list

Or maybe in 10 yrs...people ask...Mark Jankwho?
- Iggysbff

Hey, he hasn't be a healthy scratch yet!!

I think you should preemptively add Bartschi to the wingers group
- B_def

Well he could. He has played 5 games for us.

Colin Dambrauskas: Picking the Calgary Flames All Time Greatest Team – Part 3 – The Centermen
- Colin Dambrauskas

This is just sad...

What about Marc Savard?

What about Marc Savard?
- Fotiu666

Thing about Savard, is he really only developed his game to another level after leaving Calgary. I get the sense that those who will be running the league itself wanted us to keep to players who had a siginificant contribution to their respective team...Savard was a great center, but was just "decent" with the Flames.

305pts with Boston in 304gp
154pts with Calgary in 221gp

This is just sad...
- muffin_man

...Sorry?

This would be my top Montreal list....is it better? Yes. Is it MUCH better? Not so sure...many of these guys were from the 1920-1950 era where goals were really high.

Acton, Keith
Backstrom, Ralph
Beliveau, Jean
Carbonneau, Guy
Damphousse, Vincent
Koivu, Saku
Lach, Elmer
Mahovlich, Peter
Mondou, Pierre
Moore, Richardie
Morenz, Howie
Richard, Henri
Smith, Bobby

when they do the seattle alltime team list
- numbear

Exactly!!

...Sorry?

This would be my top Montreal list....is it better? Yes. Is it MUCH better? Not so sure...many of these guys were from the 1920-1950 era where goals were really high.

Acton, Keith
Backstrom, Ralph
Beliveau, Jean
Carbonneau, Guy
Damphousse, Vincent
Koivu, Saku
Lach, Elmer
Mahovlich, Peter
Mondou, Pierre
Moore, Richardie
Morenz, Howie
Richard, Henri
Smith, Bobby
- Colin Dambrauskas

Come EK, this is blasphemy

...Sorry?

This would be my top Montreal list....is it better? Yes. Is it MUCH better? Not so sure...many of these guys were from the 1920-1950 era where goals were really high.

Acton, Keith
Backstrom, Ralph
Beliveau, Jean
Carbonneau, Guy
Damphousse, Vincent
Koivu, Saku
Lach, Elmer
Mahovlich, Peter
Mondou, Pierre
Moore, Richardie
Morenz, Howie
Richard, Henri
Smith, Bobby
- Colin Dambrauskas

Seriously?