MacInns, MacCrimmon, Regher, Reinhart, Phanuef, Suter

I know there is a lot of young guys on this site so a lot of these votes are skewed towards the newer guys so it was nice to Housley getting some love. For a lot of years he was the only guy worth watching in this town.

Didn't get a lot of respect, but a great skater and passer.

Not that he's on my top 6 list but Giordano is ahead of many of the options given.

Not that he's on my top 6 list but Giordano is ahead of many of the options given.
- tincup

Believe me, it was hard enough to keep it down to around 22-24 players

very solid defensive core. so much stronger than edm's.

al, gary, phil, robyn, jaimie and dion

MacInns, MacCrimmon, Regher, Reinhart, Phanuef, Suter
- glove_was_stuck

IMO Housley and Macoun belong there ahead of Reggie and Neon Dion.

IMO Housley and Macoun belong there ahead of Reggie and Neon Dion.
- jtommyt

macoun prob wont get a ton of love, but he absolutely belongs on the list. very solid

MacInnis
Macoun
Phaneuf
Regehr
Reinhart
Suter

I know there is a lot of young guys on this site so a lot of these votes are skewed towards the newer guys so it was nice to Housley getting some love. For a lot of years he was the only guy worth watching in this town.

Didn't get a lot of respect, but a great skater and passer.
- scoot174

Sorry grandpa!

Sorry grandpa!
- bradjc

Hey I get it. Not quite a Grandpa, but my Dad would talk about Richard Duff, Johnny Bauer, Dave Keon and Normy Ullman and I would be like.... who the hell are those guys.

Not that he's on my top 6 list but Giordano is ahead of many of the options given.
- tincup

Agreed I'd take him over Jbow, Gauthier, Morris and such any day.

Hey I get it. Not quite a Grandpa, but my Dad would talk about Richard Duff, Johnny Bauer, Dave Keon and Normy Ullman and I would be like.... who the hell are those guys.
- scoot174

Come Ek... his name is D!ck Duff... not Richard Duff

IMO Housley and Macoun belong there ahead of Reggie and Neon Dion.
- jtommyt

I agree.

Reggie and Macoun are almost interchangeable. For we they are a wash.

Phaneuf...was good when with the flames, so in not considering what he's done lately. he could sneak in as the 6th. But Housely definitely should be in before him

Macinnis, Suter, Reinhart, Housely, with Macoun, Reggie, Phaneuf fighting for the final 2 spots.

If points are the decider, its phaneuf
If considering what they did as a shut down player, Macoun/Reggie are the choices.

I agree.

Reggie and Macoun are almost interchangeable. For we they are a wash.

Phaneuf...was good when with the flames, so in not considering what he's done lately. he could sneak in as the 6th. But Housely definitely should be in before him

Macinnis, Suter, Reinhart, Housely, with Macoun, Reggie, Phaneuf fighting for the final 2 spots.

If points are the decider, its phaneuf
If considering what they did as a shut down player, Macoun/Reggie are the choices.
- numbear

I have to put McCrimmon in. Mr. Steady back there... always pushing the puck up the ice. It just seemed like everytime he was on the ice the play went in the right direction.

Uh MacInnis was drafted 15th overall not 1st. The Flames have never drafted in the top 5.

Stop poisoning the rest of the country with your meat Alberta.
- trolleytracks

I'm shocked at how many votes reggie is getting... Not because he wasn't good. In his prime he was a premiere shut down guy... But on this list for me, he's maybe number 8 or 9... Right now he's almost tied with Housley. That's crazy to me.
- jtommyt

Only iginla has played more games as a Flame. That definately works in his favour.

MacInnis
Regehr
Warrener
Phaneuf
Suter
Macoun

Not that he's on my top 6 list but Giordano is ahead of many of the options given.
- tincup

I agree Gio should have been on the list for sure.

My list in order

1. MacInnis
2. Reinhart
3. Suter
4. McCrimmon
5. Macoun
6. Regehr

Honorable mention: Housley, Russell, Phaneuf, Giordano

LOL. How does Commodore get 6% ? The only time he got in the line up is when someone was hurt.

Uh MacInnis was drafted 15th overall not 1st. The Flames have never drafted in the top 5.
- flamminghead

Thanks for catching that...I can miss a few things when writing so many mini bio's

Im putting together the list of centers for you guys to pick from...and it seems the other bloggers are trying to stick to players who played the "majority" of their career with the team.

Doug Gilmour...played most games with the Leafs, but won a cup with the Flames...what do you guys think?

Flames total gp - 266 - cup
Toronto total gp - 393
St Louis total gp - 384

LOL. How does Commodore get 6% ? The only time he got in the line up is when someone was hurt.
- tincup

This is the reason I included him....

Im putting together the list of centers for you guys to pick from...and it seems the other bloggers are trying to stick to players who played the "majority" of their career with the team.

Doug Gilmour...played most games with the Leafs, but won a cup with the Flames...what do you guys think?

Flames total gp - 266 - cup
Toronto total gp - 393
St Louis total gp - 384
- Colin Dambrauskas

Gilmour was key to that cup win. He should be on the list for sure IMO. Plus that list is going to be embarrassing after the first few names or so.