Dumba rates as a top pair scoring defenseman like Phaneuf ?

Something is not right with that statement. Phaneuf in the same sentence as 'top pair' is just wrong. Also considering this kid could be a franchise defenseman you really could have chosen a better comparison.
- Pairo11

Remember when the world was in love with the 20 goal massive hitting 60 point Dion? That's about what Dumba can be but with better speed, a less erratic shot and less size.

why is Rielly's potential only 2-3 D-man?? Karlsson won the Norris, is he a 2-3 guy? I think not. As for the beer thing.. Id like to see a list of the most popular beer for each province..

So who would you think be in the top 10?

So who would you think be in the top 10?
- koarik91

6-10 is tomorrow.

why is Rielly's potential only 2-3 D-man?? Karlsson won the Norris, is he a 2-3 guy? I think not. As for the beer thing.. Id like to see a list of the most popular beer for each province..
- Arctic_AARDVARK

Play style. He plays a very similar game with similar strengths and weaknesses.

Play style. He plays a very similar game with similar strengths and weaknesses.
- AdamFrench

okay,, we can't predict the future, and im not holding you to that, but do you not think he has potential to be a bona fide #1 guy? Im not a Rielly expert and i plan on watching him when he comes to red deer. i guess what im saying is does he have the potential to be a Doughty, Letang, or Keith?

So who would you think be in the top 10?
- koarik91

Brandon Gallagher

6-10 is tomorrow.
- AdamFrench

Why the wink? Is it a trick reply?

Brandon Gallagher
- weirdoh

Patrick Holland.

6-10 is tomorrow.
- AdamFrench

We can still discuss about it right? lol

We can still discuss about it right? lol
- koarik91

- weirdoh

Lesson 1: Don't argue with weirdoh.

okay,, we can't predict the future, and im not holding you to that, but do you not think he has potential to be a bona fide #1 guy? Im not a Rielly expert and i plan on watching him when he comes to red deer. i guess what im saying is does he have the potential to be a Doughty, Letang, or Keith?
- Arctic_AARDVARK

He doesn't have anything close to the physicality of Letang or Doughty. Keith is a closer thing though Rielly isn't anywhere close to as good in his own end (atm of course). There's always a chance.

Rattie played almost as well when Sven was gone so I don't think overrated is really a theme with him. The entire team could be questioned like that considering they are such a powerhouse if you wanted to, same as guys of the Sea Dogs. If they were kept together at the NHL level that would be nuts, they play off each other so well.
- AdamFrench

as much as I would like to see if Rattie/Baert could carry that to the NHL. Giving up Jbo for Rattie and a pick isn't worth it. A play now player would have to come back that filled a hole immediately (like stewart or Polak) instead of a pick.

He doesn't have anything close to the physicality of Letang or Doughty. Keith is a closer thing though Rielly isn't anywhere close to as good in his own end (atm of course). There's always a chance.
- AdamFrench

So let's say Andrei Markov?

So let's say Andrei Markov?
- jugkope

I see what you did there.

I see what you did there.
- AdamFrench

Doesn't mean you disagree.

So let's say Andrei Markov?
- jugkope

Lidstrom

Remember when the world was in love with the 20 goal massive hitting 60 point Dion? That's about what Dumba can be but with better speed, a less erratic shot and less size.
- AdamFrench

And more hockey sense and a brain in his head.

And more hockey sense and a brain in his head.
- Iggysbff

Phaneuf is far better than any D on the Oilers

And more hockey sense and a brain in his head.
- Iggysbff

Ya well listen here buddy




















I gots nothing....anyone??

Mikey St. Croix on the 6-10 list?

Good list!!
...now what about the rest of the Czech beer list, and while you're at it, how about a good Canadian beer list, as well?
thanks!
- randycane

Czech Beer list

#1: All of them. They all taste the same. Which is fooking delicious!

Canadian Beer list

#1: Netherworld (Flying Mokeys Brewing, Guelph). A Cascadian dark IPA. Like drinking with the Gods...
#2: Total eclipse of the hop (Howe sound, Vancouver). Delicious IPA. More hops than you can shake a hop stick at.
#3: Indigo Drago double IPA (Alley Kat, Edmonton). Hoppy with a caramel finish. Omnomnomnom
#4: Blanche de Chambly (Unibroue, Chambly QC) A canadian take on a belgian style trappist ale. Amazing winter beer
#5: Robson Street Hefeweizen (Granville island brewing, Vancouver). The best pure hefe available in western Canada.

You're welcome

Mikey St. Croix on the 6-10 list?
- GOODPLAYA20

Who????

Czech Beer list

#1: All of them. They all taste the same. Which is fooking delicious!

Canadian Beer list

#1: Netherworld (Flying Mokeys Brewing, Guelph). A Cascadian dark IPA. Like drinking with the Gods...
#2: Total eclipse of the hop (Howe sound, Vancouver). Delicious IPA. More hops than you can shake a hop stick at.
#3: Indigo Drago double IPA (Alley Kat, Edmonton). Hoppy with a caramel finish. Omnomnomnom
#4: Blanche de Chambly (Unibroue, Chambly QC) A canadian take on a belgian style trappist ale. Amazing winter beer
#5: Robson Street Hefeweizen (Granville island brewing, Vancouver). The best pure hefe available in western Canada.

You're welcome
- lumlums

THANKS...Sounds like i need to do a major road trip!
anywhere i could get them all?