That's ridiculous. Did you see the return for Nash? I imagine half that for Luongo
- Leafmania84

What exactly has Nash done compared to Luongo?

Nash is more overrated the Jordan Staal.

Oh God, Scoob's plan is working beautifully
- As_I_See_It

Not so much..

He's still going to be wearing his Luongo footies come April 1st...

What exactly has Nash done compared to Luongo?

Nash is more overrated the Jordan Staal.
- Scooby_Doo

........um, got traded..

What exactly has Nash done compared to Luongo?

Nash is more overrated the Jordan Staal.
- Scooby_Doo

..................... nash>J.Staal... and your comparing a goalie to a forward... nice logic

Mike Augello: Bernier Buzz; Leafs Q & A - July 24th Edition
- mikeinbuffalo

why do these rumours keep popping up? reimer is better than bernier. it makes no sense to make that deal.

the reality is that the leafs either get a veteran to play behind reimer or they get a #1, like luongo, and let reimer develop behind him for 4 years.

if you look at what bishop brought, what lindback got, etc., bernier has no more worth than those guys based on nhl experience. those are the facts.

What exactly has Nash done compared to Luongo?

Nash is more overrated the Jordan Staal.
- Scooby_Doo

What has Lou done? Don't say gold medal, because when you pull on the maple leaf at an Olympic or WC event you've got a 1 in 4 chance

..................... nash>J.Staal... and your comparing a goalie to a forward... nice logic
- Mapleleafs_91

no he's not.

nash is over rated and will crash and burn. staal is the better player. they're both canadian, but if I have to choose one it's not rick i can't get a hat trick and my name's not steve nash. rangers will send him to the minors to play with redden before all is said and done.

..................... nash>J.Staal... and your comparing a goalie to a forward... nice logic
- Mapleleafs_91

Did you read his post about nashs return?

You guys would be lucky to get Luongo

why do these rumours keep popping up? reimer is better than bernier. it makes no sense to make that deal.

the reality is that the leafs either get a veteran to play behind reimer or they get a #1, like luongo, and let reimer develop behind him for 4 years.

if you look at what bishop brought, what lindback got, etc., bernier has no more worth than those guys based on nhl experience. those are the facts.
- therealagent

These rumours keep popping up because we dont know if reimer will bounce back. If we get bernier, we have bernier, reimer, scrivens all fighting for the number one job along with backup or they can even share the load of games. With Luu on the other hand, i dont think were ready for him but he could be a huge help. Really doesnt matter to me which route burke takes for goalie, he will pick one of bernier or Luu at the end of this all.

What exactly has Nash done compared to Luongo?

Nash is more overrated the Jordan Staal.
- Scooby_Doo

Nash is a 30/40 goal guy...that's a solid addition and he got scraps for return

Did you read his post about nashs return?

You guys would be lucky to get Luongo
- Scooby_Doo

why would we be lucky to get luongo. Hes 33 turning 34 when our team is not even playoff ready to compete. How does this help?

Did you read his post about nashs return?

You guys would be lucky to get Luongo
- Scooby_Doo

You guys will be even luckier to trade him

no he's not.

nash is over rated and will crash and burn. staal is the better player. they're both canadian, but if I have to choose one it's not rick i can't get a hat trick and my name's not steve nash. rangers will send him to the minors to play with redden before all is said and done.
- therealagent

your on crack my friend. Id pick nash over the sedin sisters any day and kesler.

What has Lou done? Don't say gold medal, because when you pull on the maple leaf at an Olympic or WC event you've got a 1 in 4 chance
- Leafmania84

gold medal. 1 in 4 chance? how do you figure?

he makes the leafs a playoff team. it's not rocket science dude. his best seasons were in a defensive system. carlye ain't necessarily putting the 80's oilers edition on the ice. he's got a bunch of plumbers to work with and they'll trap you all over the ice. it's a match made in heaven.

you'll thank us while you're in your luongo underoos eating cheetos with one tube sock every saturday when the leafs are on hnic (every saturday we have to watch that crap so i may as well watch a goalie i like for once).

These rumours keep popping up because we dont know if reimer will bounce back. If we get bernier, we have bernier, reimer, scrivens all fighting for the number one job along with backup or they can even share the load of games. With Luu on the other hand, i dont think were ready for him but he could be a huge help. Really doesnt matter to me which route burke takes for goalie, he will pick one of bernier or Luu at the end of this all.
- Mapleleafs_91

Agreed. It's gonna be one of the two...too much smoke for this not to catch before the season starts

your on crack my friend. Id pick nash over the sedin sisters any day and kesler.
- Mapleleafs_91

you're joking right?

Luongo will fetch a return of a fringe 2nd liner, a 3rd pairing Dman, and a 3rd round pick.

You heard it here.

you're joking right?
- GuyLaDouche

sedins are soft. And i say nash is the better player than kesler or equal maybe kesler but the sedins can go (frank) themselves

thank god the sedins didnt come to toronto

gold medal. 1 in 4 chance? how do you figure?

he makes the leafs a playoff team. it's not rocket science dude. his best seasons were in a defensive system. carlye ain't necessarily putting the 80's oilers edition on the ice. he's got a bunch of plumbers to work with and they'll trap you all over the ice. it's a match made in heaven.

you'll thank us while you're in your luongo underoos eating cheetos with one tube sock every saturday when the leafs are on hnic (every saturday we have to watch that crap so i may as well watch a goalie i like for once).
- therealagent

I agree with the Luongo state,ent. I'd 100% take the guy in a heart beat...but to give up Reilly, gardener and a first for a guy who has stated he'd like a move if it "helps the team" I don't think it's reasonable to think you'll get more than Nash...and I'd argue you will get less because of contract and the age of the player.

Ps stop peeking in my windows when I'm watching hnic

Luongo will fetch a return of a fringe 2nd liner, a 3rd pairing Dman, and a 3rd round pick.

You heard it here.
- IRON.MAIDEN

And the leafs will miss the playoffs, again.

Heard here fifth.

And the leafs will miss the playoffs, again.

Heard here fifth.
- Scooby_Doo

Vancouver will never win the cup. You heard it here

sedins are soft. And i say nash is the better player than kesler or equal maybe kesler but the sedins can go (frank) themselves
- Mapleleafs_91

I have no great fondness for Vancouver but the Sedins>Nash, soft or not. They instantly make a team way better than "I make 7.8 million a year but have only topped 70 pts once" Rick Nash.

gold medal. 1 in 4 chance? how do you figure?

he makes the leafs a playoff team. it's not rocket science dude. his best seasons were in a defensive system. carlye ain't necessarily putting the 80's oilers edition on the ice. he's got a bunch of plumbers to work with and they'll trap you all over the ice. it's a match made in heaven.

you'll thank us while you're in your luongo underoos eating cheetos with one tube sock every saturday when the leafs are on hnic (every saturday we have to watch that crap so i may as well watch a goalie i like for once).
- therealagent

Is it just me or does this sound like it's coming from experience?

I have no great fondness for Vancouver but the Sedins>Nash, soft or not. They instantly make a team way better than "I make 7.8 million a year but have only topped 70 pts once" Rick Nash.
- GuyLaDouche

Nash isn't that good. He's not a franchise player like many think.