jrsamu
Season Ticket Holder |
|
Joined: 11.07.2014
|
|
|
I suspect Manning is in the Indianhead because one of Gus or Forsling won't be. The organization has made the call and they'll be part of some kind of deal either this summer or fall.
And the Hawks would have to be out of their minds (and setting themselves up for the next cap problem) if they give Schmaltz 6x6 after one productive season. Playing with Kane. I really like the kid. If he was a center and a 53% faceoff guy to boot, maybe there is room for discussion. Piling up points on a massively suboptimal team isn't enough for me. |
|
Mr Ricochet
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
Location: Joliet, IL Joined: 04.19.2009
|
|
|
Okay context: Gus saw higher QOC, had marginally higher QOT (like barely worth noting), and had more OZS. Manning's zone deployment was skewed highly to the NZ - he got Murphy's deployment, pretty much, if you want a more direct comparison. Looking at notes from the Flyers SBN guys, it's because Manning was being deployed against the lower comp more deliberately. Q skewed Gus's zone deployment but not his comp; Flyers skewed Manning's comp but not his zone deployment. Both were sheltered in some way but Gus was ultimately better on a objectively worse team, at least this past season.
- L_B_R
You missed the point. My question was about that particular side by side comparison chart as a stand alone. Without going to 2-3-4-5-6 other sources of fancy stat info to give that chart context.
I always looked at that particular chart and thought there are so many more variables needed to give that chart context/meaning.
Again in the fancy stat world going by your analysis of them Manning sucks out loud. Bottom 20 of 1,000 players ain't good..... Appreciate your effort very much.
|
|
Mr Ricochet
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
Location: Joliet, IL Joined: 04.19.2009
|
|
|
Just a quick look at some more or less comparables:
J.T. MILLER
5 x 5.25
BO HORVAT
6 x 5.5
MIKA ZIBANEJAD
5 x 5.36
NINO NIEDERREITER
5 x 5.25
JONATHAN DROUIN
6 x 5.5 - walleyeb1
Nice, Walleye. That list tells me 5 mil per for 6yrs is fair if they were gonna bridge him today.
|
|
L_B_R
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Joined: 02.23.2014
|
|
|
You missed the point. My question was about that particular side by side comparison chart as a stand alone. Without going to 2-3-4-5-6 other sources of fancy stat info to give that chart context.
I always looked at that particular chart and thought there are so many more variables needed to give that chart context/meaning.
Again in the fancy stat world going by your analysis of them Manning sucks out loud. Bottom 20 of 1,000 players ain't good..... Appreciate your effort very much. - Mr Ricochet
Yes, in general those charts are just the start / basis of a comparison, breaking down by percentile, and meant for a quick look. Which was why when I first posted the chart, I said "in their role as bottom pair d-men" or something like it, meaning I was implying that their context info was similar enough that the charts were justifiable in use of comparison.
|
|
kwolf68
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Mt. Lebanon, PA Joined: 12.18.2010
|
|
|
Nice, Walleye. That list tells me 5 mil per for 6yrs is fair if they were gonna bridge him today. - Mr Ricochet
This is where I believe the numbers should fall. A good team/player compromise. There is also more upside to Schmaltz as well. |
|
SteveRain
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
Location: Connor Murphy Sucks, IL Joined: 05.07.2010
|
|
|
Okay so Bowman is a f up, i get it worst gm in the land. Pitt/Det/Boston/LA were the heavy hitters in the past 10 years including the Blackhawks. Detroit hung but to no avail, Pitt was able to draft enough talent to be a factor again but were quiet for a few years until Sullivan and Kessel came along to put the team over the top. LA old and heavy team and Boston just not all that anymore. Let me know where there is a gm who can manage the cap, keep all his young players, pay all his core players, draft studs and keep all their draft picks? Please enlighten me? - BetweenTheDots
Doug Wilson seems to be doing a fairly good job. They’ve been competitive just as long and are loaded. |
|
z1990z
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: NW USA Joined: 02.09.2012
|
|
|
Doug Wilson seems to be doing a fairly good job. They’ve been competitive just as long and are loaded. - SteveRain
A very Ehhhh day for Stanley. Lets hope a trade or something is in the works. |
|
-Doh-
|
|
Location: VA Joined: 10.05.2015
|
|
|
I am ok with today.
The Ward signing might indicate some question about Crow.
If Ward, Kunitz and and Manning work out great. If not they can be the backup goalie, 13th forward and 7th defender in the press box. It is better to keep a kid in Rockford playing regularly on an top line or top pairing than having them play every fourth game in Chicago and spend the other 3 in the press box. All are fairly short term deals.
Does anyone know if Forsberg can go back to Sweden with the Hawks still retaining his rights?
I could see the Hawks sending Jersey or Ottawa AA, Oesterle and Hossa's contract for a draft pick. Then trying to sign or trade for a 2nd line center or two. Vermette? D Grant? Wingels? Filppula?
As of now
Saad - Toews - Hino
Dcat - AA - Kane
Kunitz - Schmaltz - Sikura
Martinsen - Kampf - Hayden
Murphy - Keith
Seabs - Gus
Rutta - Manning
Crow
Ward
If Crow is healthy all year and stands on his head the Hawks could battle for the last playoff spot. That is assuming no other major injuries, the core plays better, the D plays better, a couple of the young players step up. A lot to ask (even for an optimist. If Crow goes on LTIR and they do not move Hossa's contract they have $11,275 mil in cap space on day one of the season. Should they be in contention they could make TDL moves.
If things head South the contracts today are small and short term and the Hawks have a very good pick in next years draft. Prospect pool is deepening.
After nearly 50 pretty sad years the Hawks won 3 cups in the last 9 years. I am ok with a few ugly years. |
|
TJYTJY
Season Ticket Holder Chicago Blackhawks |
|
Joined: 05.23.2017
|
|
|
Is there any way to pry Anders Lee away from the Islanders? |
|
kwolf68
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Mt. Lebanon, PA Joined: 12.18.2010
|
|
|
Is there any way to pry Anders Lee away from the Islanders? - TJYTJY
I doubt it after losing Tavares. |
|
SteveRain
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
Location: Connor Murphy Sucks, IL Joined: 05.07.2010
|
|
|
I am ok with today.
The Ward signing might indicate some question about Crow.
If Ward, Kunitz and and Manning work out great. If not they can be the backup goalie, 13th forward and 7th defender in the press box. It is better to keep a kid in Rockford playing regularly on an top line or top pairing than having them play every fourth game in Chicago and spend the other 3 in the press box. All are fairly short term deals.
Does anyone know if Forsberg can go back to Sweden with the Hawks still retaining his rights?
I could see the Hawks sending Jersey or Ottawa AA, Oesterle and Hossa's contract for a draft pick. Then trying to sign or trade for a 2nd line center or two. Vermette? D Grant? Wingels? Filppula?
As of now
Saad - Toews - Hino
Dcat - AA - Kane
Kunitz - Schmaltz - Sikura
Martinsen - Kampf - Hayden
Murphy - Keith
Seabs - Gus
Rutta - Manning
Crow
Ward
If Crow is healthy all year and stands on his head the Hawks could battle for the last playoff spot. That is assuming no other major injuries, the core plays better, the D plays better, a couple of the young players step up. A lot to ask (even for an optimist. If Crow goes on LTIR and they do not move Hossa's contract they have $11,275 mil in cap space on day one of the season. Should they be in contention they could make TDL moves.
If things head South the contracts today are small and short term and the Hawks have a very good pick in next years draft. Prospect pool is deepening.
After nearly 50 pretty sad years the Hawks won 3 cups in the last 9 years. I am ok with a few ugly years. - -Doh-
In a major market and with all this “one goal” BS my expectations as a fan is to be in the playoffs.
After they got waxed by Nashville this organization was “mad” and they got worse. Now it seems they’ve accepted their demise internally and have been caught with a lack of nhl ready prospects. So we get the white Sox approach of signing names people recognize but players long past their prime. None of today’s additions make this team better.
Kunitz is timmonen part 2
Manning is a steaming pile of crap
Ward will take forsbergs spot and with CC’s deal up after next year it would be nice to know if this kid has any chance to be a 1
The 3 cup wins are history. Lately this organization has failed and hasn’t won a playoff game since 2016. Baring a string of bounce back years and health that winless streak isn’t breaking this year.
So let’s see what Stan does in the trade market.
I’d also begin to wonder when a 2/19/88 start to ponder asking for a trade for a last chance to win. 19/88 wasting prime years as they miss the playoffs......especially 88
|
|
walleyeb1
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Petersburg, IL Joined: 09.25.2014
|
|
|
Is there any way to pry Anders Lee away from the Islanders? - TJYTJY
Sure, but it’d take a lot. Probably more than we’d want to give up. He also has a big payday coming up. |
|
StLBravesFan
Season Ticket Holder Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: IL Joined: 07.03.2011
|
|
|
Just a quick look at some more or less comparables:
J.T. MILLER
5 x 5.25
BO HORVAT
6 x 5.5
MIKA ZIBANEJAD
5 x 5.36
NINO NIEDERREITER
5 x 5.25
JONATHAN DROUIN
6 x 5.5 - walleyeb1
Except for Drouin, each of your examples had several years experience, and several years of 20+ goals.
Schmaltz has much less experience, and a shorter number of quality games years.
|
|
|
|
Doug Wilson seems to be doing a fairly good job. They’ve been competitive just as long and are loaded. - SteveRain
True but he runs the team kind of like the Blackhawks he played for. Good enough to make the playoffs but comes up short to win a Cup. Rather have the 3 cups myself and be where we are now.
|
|
L_B_R
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Joined: 02.23.2014
|
|
|
For those that were hoping for the impossible. |
|
mrpaulish
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Itasca, IL Joined: 01.18.2010
|
|
|
Mother (frank)errrrrrr
Hearing Ryan O'Reilly has been traded to the St. Louis Blues |
|
Marlowe
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Wild Wild West, IL Joined: 06.29.2014
|
|
|
LeBrun
Hearing Ryan O'Reilly has been traded to the St. Louis Blues |
|
kwolf68
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Mt. Lebanon, PA Joined: 12.18.2010
|
|
|
Mother (frank)errrrrrr
Hearing Ryan O'Reilly has been traded to the St. Louis Blues - mrpaulish
Credit to Blows, they are going for it. But the ask was HUGE, I want to see what the Blows gave up. |
|
TommyHawk
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Joined: 05.23.2013
|
|
|
So now they’ve added ROR and Bozak down the middle, and Perron on the wing.
Great job down in STL. |
|
Marlowe
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Wild Wild West, IL Joined: 06.29.2014
|
|
|
So now they’ve added ROR and Bozak down the middle, and Perron on the wing.
Great job down in STL. - TommyHawk
Haven’t seen what STL had to give up to get ROR. That was a trade, not a UFA signing... |
|
Marlowe
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Wild Wild West, IL Joined: 06.29.2014
|
|
|
Credit to Blows, they are going for it. But the ask was HUGE, I want to see what the Blows gave up. - kwolf68
You and me both! |
|
Marlowe
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Wild Wild West, IL Joined: 06.29.2014
|
|
|
Cap Friendly
TRADE:
To #Blues:
F Ryan O'Reilly
To #Sabres:
2019 1st RD pick
2021 2nd RD pick
F Tage Thompson
F Patrick Betglund
F Vladimír Sobotka |
|
kwolf68
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Mt. Lebanon, PA Joined: 12.18.2010
|
|
|
You and me both! - Marlowe
The ask was a 1st, 2nd and a top prospect.... |
|
Marlowe
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Wild Wild West, IL Joined: 06.29.2014
|
|
|
The ask was a 1st, 2nd and a top prospect.... - kwolf68
Got that and then some
TRADE:
To #Blues:
F Ryan O'Reilly
To #Sabres:
2019 1st RD pick
2021 2nd RD pick
F Tage Thompson
F Patrick Betglund
F Vladimír Sobotka
EDIT: CapFriendly added
Both the 2019 1st RD pick & 2021 2nd RD pick heading to Buffalo are the #Blues own picks. |
|
kwolf68
Chicago Blackhawks |
|
|
Location: Mt. Lebanon, PA Joined: 12.18.2010
|
|
|
Got that and then some
TRADE:
To #Blues:
F Ryan O'Reilly
To #Sabres:
2019 1st RD pick
2021 2nd RD pick
F Tage Thompson
F Patrick Betglund
F Vladimír Sobotka - Marlowe
That's what Buffalo was pretty much asking, I guess Thompson is the top prospect. |
|