If the wheels are turning and I feel like we are heading in the right direction, I can forgive a lot. The era of Giroux taking over for Richards with the cast of Simmonds, Voracek and Schenn being the focus of this team was very entertaining. It looked like we had a direction…but it led to nothing.
- SuperSchennBros
It wasn't a direction so much as a forced reset due to cap considerations from Ed Snider's "never again" which resulted in Bryz.
Along with that, and Bob getting dumped, and Homer not knowing how to build a defense (Grossmann, Kubina, JVR for Schenn, etc)... that G/Simmer/Jake era really didn't have a chance. They could have been something special if they had just kept Bob and added an actual good two-way dman or two.
Ditto Homer's original "Center City" core of Richie/Carts/Lupul/Hartsy/G. All the "Dry Island" stuff was just a soap opera distraction for the real issues of weak goaltending, weak defense, bad cap management. Even the addition of Pronger couldn't fix those issues, and ended up causing more problems down the road for them.