At some point, I will probably take the standard run at doing 2013-14 individual player evaluations, but it is much more fun to look forward to next year. That is the emphasis for this blog - figuring out where the gaps are for this summer's work for Ron Francis to get ready for next season.
When I slot out the Hurricanes, for me it looks like this:
Top 6 forwards: Eric Staal, Alexander Semin, Jeff Skinner, Jordan Staal, Jiri Tlusty (RFA). The big caveat here is that same as I said 2 summers ago and same as I said last summer, I think the team works better with JStaal and Skinner on different lines, and until his 2-way play takes a big step forward, I just do not see Jeff Skinner as an every-night forward on a top line. It is just too much feast (offense going) or famine (still not up to snuff defensively when the goals are not pouring in). He was good offensively and on the power play last year. By no means do I discount that, but he continued to be challenged defensively. Because of that, I continue to think he most benefits the team on an offense-leaning 3rd line with a full helping plus some on the power play. The challenge will again be adding enough players to be 9 deep and capable of offering offensive support for Skinner on a 3rd line without shortchanging the top 2 lines. So my view has the Canes needing 2 top 6 forwards.
So the way I do it, the challenge is to find 2 more top 6 forwards and still have offensively capable help available for an offense-leaning 3rd line with Jeff Skinner.
There are a few players already in the mix who could help fill these holes: --Nathan Gerbe. I cannot imagine a scenario in which he will not be back in some way. The question is where. He does not fit so well on a Skinner line because they are both most comfortable in the same LW slot and are both undersized. Could he be the guy that goes to the dirty areas in the offensive zone and turns Semin's playmaking into goals on a Gerbe/JStaal/Semin line? Could he fit with Eric Staal?
--Andrei Loktionov (RFA). I have not had time to hunt down the latest updates on his recovery from surgery to repair an injured shoulder from the world championships. But assuming that he will be a part of the 2014-15 Canes, he looked good (after about a dozen other things were tried with zero success) on the power play and showed some sparks and potential offensively. Could he center a first line that sees Eric Staal on his wing? Could he be a playmaker centering Jeff Skinner and boosting his offense even further from what #53 already creates for himself?
--Elias Lindholm. I am still high on Lindholm's future, but in 2013-14 the future was not here yet. He was not in way over his head, but he was not a difference-maker except on limited occasions as a top 9 NHL forward. After a year to adjust and an offseason to get stronger, could he take a big leap forward? Sure. Would I count on him to be a leading top 9 forward when building the team this summer? The Canes did this last summer, and it did not work. I would not go back to that well but rather would pencil him in as a complementary player for now and hopefully be pleasantly surprised by more. He has the potential to fill 1 of the 2 top 9 RW slots not filled by Semin and also the potential to center a 3rd line though the team did ot seem too keen on moving him to that role last season.
So when I net out the top 9, I optimistically help for some help from Loktionov, Gerbe and Lindholm, but I would not count on all 3 being sure things, and I also think there is room to upgrade here. The team gets better if it can force 1-2 of these players into a depth role that offers more lineup options if line combinations/players are struggling or in the event of the inevitable injury.
That makes up to 8 top 9 forwards, but I think ideally it is more like 7 with 2 new ones to come.
Past that I view the remaining options as good depth forwards who are 4th-line players on a good team. The list includes Manny Malhotra (UFA), Patrick Dwyer, Riley Nash and Drayson Bowman. (I figure the Canes to part ways with Radek Dvorak.)
I really like the idea of bringing Malhotra back as a 4th line center and maybe sometimes healthy scratch to stay fresh. I am also okay with Nash and Dwyer as 4th-line role players. Bowman also fits okay as a 4th-line depth player if no better options come along. Because I think the budget is better spent working on bigger problems at in the top portion of the roster, I think the team might be resigned to live with a decent combination of what they already have on the 4th line. In true Chad LaRose fashion, it is when these players climb to scoring lines that they are overslotted and also an indication that the roster is too thin. Is the 4th line untouchable and/or something I am enamored with? No, but it just is not the biggest issue this summer and the players slotted there are priced right.
I refuse to lock myself into line combinations mid-June especially before the roster is even filled out, but if I was Ron Francis, right now I would think of the forwards like this:
4 of top 6: EStaal, JStaal, Semin, Tlusty. Anchor for 2B scoring line: Skinner. Potentials to fill 2 more top 9 slots: Gerbe, Lindholm, Loktionov.
I would be shopping for a big RW with enough mobility and offensive ability to be a good complement to Skinner and whoever (think skill, playmaking with enough defensive conscience) centers that line. I would be shopping for 1 more top 6-capable forward. I fear that the Canes will not be able to muster the $ to chase another true 1st-liner, so I think the aim is to find someone a bit less touted in something like a $2-3M range.
Winging a lineup early, I like something like this:
1:EStaal/Loktionov/Tlusty or Tlusty/EStaal/Lindholm or Tlusty/EStaal/_____ 2A: Gerbe/JStaal/Semin 2B: Skinner/____/_____ or Skinner/Loktionov/______ or Skinner/_______/Lindholm 4: Bowman/Malhotra/Dwyer with Nash in the mix at any of those 3 slots depending on who is playing well.
It takes a few of a couple things for this to work: --Loktionov would need to prove capable of playing like a 45-50-point offensive producer, maybe even a little more if he stuck with EStaal. --Lindholm would need to take a step up and be more than a placeholder where he lands. --Gerbe would need to be a decent 2nd-line finisher with Semin on that line (not unreasonable based on his scoring this year with less offense on that line.)
So there is my turn at playing Ron Francis...Go get a reasonably adaptable RW who you can try on 1st and 3rd lines and get me 1 more offensively capable top 9 forward ideally with some positional flexibility between RW and C.
What say you Canes fans? Is it way too early to even start talking about line combinations and slots? Or is this what gets you through another long summer like me?
Twitter=@CarolinaMatt63
Go Canes!
