Duncan Keith, Caleb Jones and Seth Jones linked together in trade talks. https://t.co/FIRlgHx0oP
β NHL Trade Talk (@nhl_tradetalk) July 2, 2021
Given that the Hawks prefer not to take much salary back in the trade presumably means that they are carving out sufficient cap space to bring in a high-end (read: high-priced) player namely either Seth Jones via trade or Dougie Hamilton via free agency.
The assumption is the top choice is Seth Jones by virtue of another assumption that Caleb Jones is being pursued as a way to entice big brother to accept a trade to Chicago and ideally re-sign a new contract shortly after rather than test free agency next summer.
To be fair, while Caleb is nowhere near the upper echelon of NHL blueliners, he's not junk either. He could be a good complementary piece to the backline much like Riley Stillman is. Stillman wasn't just a throw away in the Panthers trade to pick up Henrik Borgstrom.
It's highly doubtful, though, that the Hawks are interested in trading for Caleb with zero desire to bring aboard Seth. To put it another way, if Seth was content with staying in Columbus and didn't ask to be traded, Caleb wouldn't be on Chicago's radar.
Yet, what if the reality plays out that Caleb is acquired but the Hawks fall short of snagging Seth? Sure, the Hawks could move down the shopping list and try for Hamilton but would they be fine with having the consolation prize (Caleb) but not the main prize (Seth)?
However, it's quite plausible that the Hawks wouldn't sign on the dotted line to deal Keith for Caleb -- and any other assets on either side of the exchange -- unless they had a trade all but confirmed with the Blue Jackets to reel in Seth.
If that's the case, then that opens up another can of worms of whether it's smart to give up assets needed to consummate the trade for Seth. Doing so could halt the rebuild as young foundational blocks from Chicago would be funneled to Columbus.
Then there's the issue of blocking paths for the young rearguards, particularly the ones who have some NHL experience already like Adam Boqvist, Wyatt Kalynuk, Ian Mitchell, and Nicolas Beaudin. Not only would Seth block a path but so would Caleb.
One core assumption is any trade package for Seth is likely to include at least one of the Hawks young D-men and potentially one who is a RHD -- whether Boqvist, Mitchell, or Kalynuk who can play either side -- to replace Seth who is a RHD presently for the Jackets.
Another assumption is Calvin de Haan and Nikita Zadorov would be traded or the Kraken takes one of them in the expansion draft. If either or both are retained, then that leaves zero spots for the Hawks young D which would be counterintuitive to the rebuild.
As sample pairs:
C Jones - S Jones de Haan - Murphy Stillman - Zadorov
An observation with that starting six on the blueline is that none of them were drafted by the Hawks. A key aspect of a rebuild is drafting and grooming one's own talent. If the rebuild is still intact, where and when do Boqvist, Kalynuk, Mitchell, and/or Beaudin play?
Then again, if the Hawks are to give up futures to get Seth, then the team would seem to be recalibrating the organizational plan and moving from rebuilding to fast tracking. The problem, though, is the latter may not be feasible due to other holes on the team.
There's no going back for the Hawks if Caleb is acquired and they double down if it's then automatic that Seth is joining his brother in Chicago. The expectation going into last season was the team is rebuilding. Going into this season may be a different story.
--
See you on the boards!
