If any two bench bosses in this year's
Stanley Cup playoffs already have a colorful coaching "history" against each other -- even though they have never met in NHL post season play before -- they are
John Stevens of the
Philadelphia Flyers and
Michel Therrien of the
Pittsburgh Penguins. They may respect each other, but there is certainly no love lost between them...or as one senior NHL team executive who knows them both says:
"If you want to screw up either man's game of golf, just call out the other's name as his rival is about to make a shot."
The roads that the Flyers and Penguins have traveled over the past three seasons which have brought them to meeting each other in the
2008 Eastern Conference Finals of the Stanley Cup playoffs are quite remarkable indeed. When the two clubs returned to the ice after the lockout year with the rest of the NHL in
October, 2005, they did so sitting very much at the opposite ends of the scales of success. The Pens had finished their last season before the lockout with just
23 wins and a league worst
58 points in
2003-04 while the Flyers had won the Atlantic Division with
101 points and then pushed the eventual Stanley Cup champion
Tampa Bay Lightning to a
seventh game in the
2004 Eastern Conference Finals.
Despite the year off in
2004-05, the first season back did not start out any better for the Pens who were sitting at
8-17-6 after just
31 games when they fired head coach
Eddie Olczyk and replaced him with Michel Therrien, then coach of the Pens'
Wilkes Barre/Scranton Penguins farm club in the
AHL. Still the team again finished with just
58 points (one more than the
St. Louis Blues league worst
57) while the Flyers once again topped the century mark under
Ken Hitchcock with
101.
The
2006-07 season, however, saw the fates of both clubs make
drastic reversals.
The Penguins, in their first full season under Therrien's hand, rocketed from
58 points to
105 while the Flyers would unexpectedly plummet from
101 points to a league worst
56. After a devastating loss in
Buffalo on
October 17th in which the Flyers gave up
eight goals in less than
fifteen minutes of playing time, longtime GM
Bob Clarke resigned, head coach
Ken Hitchcock was fired,
Paul Holmgren stepped up from
Assistant GM to
"Interim" GM, and former
AHL Philadelphia Phantoms' head coach
John Stevens -- who had guided the AHL club to a
Calder Cup title in
2005 -- was promoted from his just started position as a Flyers' assistant coach to
head coach of the NHL club just eight games into the season.
Therrien and the Penguins would not make things easy for Stevens as they swept all
eight meetings in
2006-07. Despite the one sidedness of the series, however, the games were always passionate due in no small part to the intense personal competition between the men behind the benches -- John Stevens and Michel Therrien -- who were well familiar with each other from their years competing against one another in the AHL going back to
1986-87 when Stevens was a
20-year old defenseman with the
Hershey Bears and Therrien was a
23-year old blueliner for Hershey's bitterest rival, the
Baltimore Skipjacks.
The coaching rivalry between the two began in
2003-04 when Therrien, a former coach of the
Montreal Canadiens, took over the AHL Penguins and Stevens who had already been coaching the Phantoms since the
2000-01 season. As
AHL East Division rivals the two clubs met
ten times that year and
six more times in the
second round of the
Calder Cup playoffs which the Penguins won,
four-games-to-two, on their way to the play-off finals. After another ten regular season meetings in
2004-05, the two clubs and coaches again faced off in the second round of the playoffs in what would produce perhaps the most distressing and embarrassing loss in Therrien's coaching career
. (I'll have more about that in a minute.)
Things were a good bit different for the Flyers in
2007-08 -- especially against the Penguins -- as the revampted and new look club won the first
four penalty filled meetings between the two squads and finished the year with a
5-3 record over Pittsburgh. (The eight game series also featured 13 fights.) Still all was not perfect as the Flyers did suffer one quite ugly
7-1 loss in Pittsburgh on
March 16th on an
NBC Game of the Week. With only
nine games remaining in the season after that loss, it appeared that the Flyers were in considerable jeopardy of missing the play-offs if Stevens and the Flyers could not right their ship immediately....but that they did finishing as the
sixth seed when they shut-out the Pens,
2-0, on the final day of the season.
In the month that followed, the Flyers beat the
Washington Capitals in seven games and then took out the top team in the East, the
Montreal Canadiens, in five. Meanwhile the Penguins swept aside the
Ottawa Senators and
New York Rangers to set up the
all-Pennsylvania Eastern Conference final. It is also just the
fourth ever post season meeting with their cross state rivals in
forty years, and the first since
2000. (The Flyers won the previous three series in
1989, 1997, and
2000 with a
12-6 overall record in
18 games..)
While Therrien and the Penguins beat Stevens' Phantoms in
2004, it was the Phantoms that took the second round set between the two in
2005 and then went on to capturing their second
Calder Cup a month later when they defeated the
Chicago Wolves before an
SRO crowd of
20,103 at the
Wachovia Center. As thrilling as that was for the hockey starved fans of Philadelphia with no NHL hockey because of the lockout, it was the fifth and final game between the Phantoms and Penguins that Therrien and Stevens may well be thinking of as they stand behind the same two benches in Philadelphia next
Tuesday, May 13th, which will be the
third anniversary of that game. In addition to Stevens and Therrien, a number of the players sitting on their NHL benches were there as AHL'ers that night too including
Mike Richards, Jeff Carter, Riley Cote, R.J. Umberger, and
Antero Niittymaki for the Phantoms, and
Marc-Andre Fleury, Dany Sabourin, Ryan Whitney, Tomas Surovy, Rob Scuderi, Kris Beech, and
Maxime Talbot for the Pens. (Pens' assistant coach
Mike Yeo was also Therrien's assistant in the AHL.)
The Phantoms had a
three-games-to-one lead in the series when the two clubs took to the ice for game five on
May 13, 2005. Although Fleury, then a rookie pro, had played in
54 games for Wilkes Barre during the regular season (
26-19-4; 2.52; .901) his playoff performances had not been good losing his only two starts and mopping up in another loss for starter
Andy Chiodo leaving him with a goals against average of
4.36. Chiodo, a
seventh round pick of the Pens in
2003, thus got the start in the
fifth game and played well enough to be holding on to a
4-1 lead approaching then midway point of the third period. With it looking as if the Pens had the game wrapped up to set up a sixth game the next night in Wilkes Barre, Stevens pulled Niittymaki to rest him up and inserted veteran netminder
Neil Little, now a Phantom coach and the goaltender who led the club to its first Calder Cup title in
1998 when Stevens was the captain.
And then something remarkable happened as Therrien's team suffered a meltdown of truly Biblical proportions.
It all began at
8:37 of the final period when
Josh Gratton -- who was far better known for scoring with his fists than in the net -- beat Chiodo to close the score to
4-2. Just over three minutes later recent junior hockey graduate
Jeff Carter -- who would go on to be the
leading scorer in the AHL playoffs -- narrowed the deficit again to
4-3 with a power play goal at
11:45, and then
John Sim tied it at
4-4 just over a minute later at
12:49. Left wing
Ryan Ready then gave the Phantoms a
5-4 lead at
13:56 which chased Penguins' netminder Chiodo in favor of
Marc-Andre Fleury who quickly gave up a goal to
Jeff Carter at
17:20. Winger
Jon Sim finished off the
six goals in a dozen minutes outburst with an
empty netter with just under
four seconds remaining to cap the miraculous rally and give Stevens and his club a
7-4 series clinching victory.
“Once the momentum changed, it was hard to get it stopped,” said Stevens. "I don't think I have ever seen anything quite like it.
“That was the best comeback that I’ve ever seen or been a part of,” said Richards. “When Gratton scored that goal, it just lifted the bench and everyone got excited. Even though we were still behind a couple of goals, when Gratton scored, you could sense the confidence on the bench that we could do this.”
Therrien, on the other hand, had a different view of the evening's events.
"It is performances like that," he said,
"that can cost some players their careers."
Since 2004 John Stevens and Michel Therrien have faced each other from behind opposite benches almost
fifty times in the AHL and NHL and know each other well. When this Eastern Conference final ends sometime in the next two weeks one of these two coaches -- who within the last four years have each been both to an
AHL Calder Cup final, and ended an NHL season
dead last in the league -- will be going on to the
Stanley Cup finals for the first time.
And for the other one -- well it will be golf.
But
please, if you happen see him on the course, don't call out the name of the other coach when he's ready to take a swing!

"The Ultimate Prize"